Carlie Smith
100% Response Rate
Pro Agents
Pro agents have made a commitment to a higher standard of service.
- Ask every client to rate their service.
- Answer every text, call, and email promptly.
They've also proven they have the expertise from a wide variety of successful clients.
Plus Agents
Plus agents have paid for extra features on their account. Buying any kind of subscription does not impact the rankings in any way. Agents must prove their success at the Plus level before they get the opportunity to qualify for Pro.
Key Stats
Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 3 times
29 reviews in 6 cities and 2 neighbourhoods.
1st in Port Colborne, ON - 20 Reviews
7th in Welland, ON - 3 Reviews
16th in Niagara Falls, ON - 2 Reviews
6th in Fort Erie, ON - 2 Reviews
5th in Niagara, ON - 1 Reviews
26th in St Catharines, ON - 1 Reviews
Rating Summary
| Overall Rating |
|
| Knowledgeability Rating |
|
| Professionalism Rating |
|
| Responsiveness Rating |
|
| Usefulness of Website |
|
| Value of Service |
|
| Reach & Lead Generation |
|
| Home Prep & Staging Advice |
|
| Success Ratio | 100 % |
| Recommend Ratio | 100 % |
| Response Rate | 100 % |
Contact
Home Purchase in Fairview-Facer, St Catharines | Aug 2026
Carlie was the best real estate agent. She gave realistic expectations and everything she said ended up being incredibly accurate. Gave great advice that allowed us to get everything we wanted out of our buying experience. Super personable and very professional. - Kailyn Jones
Home in Stevensville, Fort Erie | Sep 2025
My husband and I had an amazing experience working with Carlie to sell our home and purchase another this past September. From start to finish, she was knowledgeable, responsive, and truly had our best interests at heart. She knew the right people to refer us to (mortgage broker, inspector), understood the detailed paperwork, and had a highly effective marketing strategy for the sale of our house. The current housing market can be stressful, but she made the entire process feel manageable and clear, always taking the time to explain options and answer questions without pressure. What stood out most was her professionalism paired with a very personal approach. We never felt like “just another client.” She was proactive, detail-oriented, and genuinely invested in helping us get the best deal for our home. We’re so grateful for her guidance and support and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell. - Emily Brown
Home Sale in Port Colborne | Jan 2026
Carlie worked with us to sell our home during one of the slowest markets, always proving her professionalism, dedication, and perseverance. She was always quick to offer suggestions when needed and we never felt alone. We would recommend Carlie to anyone looking to purchase or sell their home in a heartbeat! Thank you Carlie for helping to make our dream come true! - Shelly Marie Creighton
Home Sale in Niagara Falls | Jul 2025
About Carlie Smith: Recommended by a happy family member. Immediately impressed-Cheery, Knowledgeable, Honest & our 'lil' pooch liked her too. Listened intently to us! Understood our situation. Patient with us and not pushy at all. Has same values; a high commitment to "gifting' both her time in volunteering and funds; a portion of all her sales goes to EDI charities of which she is an advocate. Knew & explained the fluctuating market trends realistically. Used all marketing tools available, including post cards, video, positive listing and photos & marketing outside the region as well as social media. Open house well planned and executed. Colorful outdoor signage drew positive attention. Very professional and returned calls, emails quickly. Always available. Carlie, highly enthusiastic and positive, sold our house in a tough market within months. Thank you! ~Wendy & Mary Beth - Wendy
Home Sale in Port Colborne | Jan 2026
Carlie is the best realtor you could ever hope to work with! We worked with Carlie for about 3 years, trying to find our next home in such a crazy time for buying and selling. Throughout the entire process Carlie was so amazing and was always answering any questions & concerns we had. When the time finally came for us to sell our home, Carlie explained everything so well & we never had any doubt that she would list our little home the right way so it would sell and sell fast as we had a deadline. Within 3 weeks we had our offer & the deal was done! Carlie's knowledge of the real estate market & that she is such a people person and really cares about her clients sets her apart from other realtors. She is such a pleasure to work with, and actually cares about you and your family, not just about selling another house. Every interaction or house showing we had never felt like a business deal, just like a meet up with a friend. Even our children always loved her. We are now lifelong friends & forever clients. Carlie would be our only pick if we had to do this all over again! You will not be disappointed using Carlie for buying & selling! - Sarah VanderHeide
Home Sale in Port Colborne | Jan 2026
Carlie is a top notch seller. It’s a pleasure to have her work for me selling my house. Fantastic communications. She keeps you updated on everything going on with the sale. Carlie makes selling your house very easy and stress free. I would highly recommend her to sell your home. I’m so thankful to have met her and will never forget what she has done for me. Thank you again Charlie. Your the best - Mark Currie
Home Sale in Welland | Dec 2025
Carlie Smith was an absolute joy to work with, it was/is a tough market for sellers, Carlie made sure my house got maximum exposure on line and in the paper, we had many showings and open houses and it sold, not right away but it wasn't on the market for very long. Carlie made the entire process stress free and I would definitely recommend her to sell your house . - Dave Sabo
Home Purchase in Port Colborne | Dec 2025
Carlie has been an absolute godsend when purchasing our first home. What seemed like a stressful, daunting task turned into an enjoyable smoothe experience with her help every step of the way. She pointed us in the right direction for every thing related to buying a home, and answered all of our questions. She made sure we understood all the intricacies that go into a home purchase and I never once felt overwhelmed with the experience. She always responded quickly and thoroughly, and it always felt like we were her first priority, even though we knew she had a billion other things on the go! If we sell our house in the future, she will be the first call we make because I couldn't imagine the experience without her. Five stars isn't nearly enough to show just how amazing she is! - Sara Smith-Scolaro
Home in Port Colborne | Jun 2021
Carlie is the most personable and knowledgeable Realtor. She made us feel confident in the decision to both buy and sell. Carlie guided us through the whole process in a way that felt super personal and professional at the same time. I can’t recommend Carlie Smith enough! She’s just the best. - Wylie Needham
Home in Port Colborne | Feb 2025
We loved having Carlie Smith as our realtor for buying and selling! So helpful and professional. She is so up beat and makes you smile every time you see her. Highly recommend her! - Donna Beam
Home Sale in Port Colborne | Jun 2025
My sister and I were trying to help my 89yr old mother sell her final home. We meet with a couple of brokers but Carlie, stood out immediately making my mom comfortable! Quick and eager to help and set up appointments, patient helping explain the process to my mother and willing to go above and beyond with making the process enjoyable and simple for our family. With OPEN communication together we built a strategy and put it into effect. We took the necessary time to make sure everything was in order before the picture and listing went live. In a down market with many homes in the price range we had 5 showings on opening day and a 3 more booked for day two with an open house to follow. Obviously, Carlie's marketing team killed it. Carlie's hard work pulled multiple offers with a quick and clean closing over asking. That is GREAT!!! The TRUTH is this experience with Carlie was even better! My mother was 100% comfortable and Carlie made sure of that. I would highly recommend Carlie to all my friends and family in Niagara. I have over 30 years in yacht sales, let me tell you ethics, integrity, honesty and negotiating are the keys reasons for Carlies success in my opinion. Thank you very much Carlie, you made mom proud! - Kevin Marinelli
Home in Welland | Jun 2025
Carlie was referred to us by a good friend, and from the moment she walked into our home for the first time, we knew she was the right person to guide us through this journey. She was honest and transparent about the current trends in the real estate market and her plan to get us into our next home. She never shied away from the challenges that come with buying and selling a house—always making sure our questions were answered and that we felt supported through the stressful moments. She also introduced us to her trusted inspector and lawyer—both wonderful to work with—who helped put us even more at ease through the final steps. From late-night video calls and Sunday afternoon showings to final walk-throughs and picking paint colours, she never hesitated to be there for us. She knew exactly when to push and when to pull, and I truly believe she’s the reason we’re lucky enough to be living in our forever home. Even though we won’t be moving again anytime soon, Carlie Smith will always be the first name we share with friends and family when they’re ready to buy or sell. And to top it all off, she absolutely spoiled our dog with love, attention and treats—if Oakley could talk, she’d be singing Carlie’s praises too! - Andrea Wiley
Home Purchase in Port Colborne | Feb 2025
Carlie helped my husband and I find our first home! She is exceptional at what she does! She connects with her clients by showing genuine interest in their passions. As first time home buyers, Carlie helped us through every step of the process. She was always readily available, offered valued opinions, and answered every question. Carlie's organization and attention to detail allowed us to find a home where we can raise our family that was within our budget, aligned with our timeline, and checked off even more boxes than we'd put on our list! And her dedication to supporting communities and causes is truly incredible! We would highly recommend Carlie to anyone looking to buy or sell! - Cass Greene
Home Sale in Welland | Feb 2025
Absolutely amazing working Carlie! Smooth and simple sale of home. Would recommend to everyone. Very patient, polite, professional and prompt, Carlie went above and beyond and really worked hard towards the presentation and process of selling the home. - Tom Fulop
Home Sale in Port Colborne | Aug 2024
Carlie is amazing ! I am so glad I called her. We had our house on the market prior to calling with no luck. I called Carlie to relist. She was incredibly professional, and prompt. Our house was listed, (professional pictures and all) and sold within a month for the price we wanted. She is so dedicated to her work. I would not hesitate to call her for any future listing or purchases ! Thank you Carlie for helping my family on their next adventure. - Brianna Bodorkos
Home Purchase in Port Colborne | May 2021
Home in Port Colborne | Sep 2024
Carlie is the best of the best. Incredibly hard working, knowledgeable and honest, Carlie goes above and beyond to give her clients the best experience possible. My husband and I felt so incredibly supported by Carlie throughout the process of buying and selling. While providing her expertise and recommendations, she never once made us feel pressured to make certain decisions. She is an exceptional friend first ahead of being an exceptional realtor. We couldn't recommend her more. - Michelle
Home in Fort Erie | Sep 2024
Carlie did an amazing job as our real estate agent ! She was very available and professional throughout the entire process. We were able to sell our old house and purchase our new house with 0 issue. I can’t recommend Carlie enough to people looking to buy or sell. - Lucas Schinkel
Home Sale in Port Colborne | Aug 2024
Home Sale in Niagara Falls | Oct 2024
We are so happy to have chosen Carlie to sell our parents' house! The house sold quickly and at a price that exceeded our expectations. Carlie impressed me from the start, touring the property she noticed everything and offered prioritized suggestions and advice to prepare the property for listing. The listing was top notch, and the drone video was just amazing, we were blown away by it! Throughout the process Carlie remained informative and extremely supportive, she took extra time to explain processes and document, accommodating our families schedules for meetings and document signing. It was a pleasure working with Carlie, without hesitation my go to agent in the Niagara region! - Robert Grandoni
Home in Port Colborne | Dec 2024
Where to even begin? Carlie is one of the most kindhearted, passionate, dedicated, and down to earth person, let alone realtor, that I know. She has helped us with two sales of our homes and finding our new home with ease, intelligence and go-getter attitude. She advocates and fights for her clients and delivers every time. She makes an overwhelming process seem so easy. She reasons with you, is honest and will support you through the entire process. I have never met a more hard working professional who treats her clients as family. - madison Napper
Home Sale in Port Colborne | Jun 2024
Carlie was outstanding to work with from start to finish. She is pleasant, professional, knoweldgeable and remained focused on our listing throughout. Her guidance on the market was spot on and her recommendations regarding marketing were focused and very helpful. We could not have been more satisfied! - Tom May
Home Sale in Port Colborne | Jun 2024
Carlie was a pleasure to work with. Right from start to finish she made herself available to both us as sellers and to answer questions purchasers had. She is pleasant, well spoken, knowledgeable and very professional. We truly appreciated her assistance in selling our parents home. She helped make this difficult task more bearable. Thank you Carlie for your compassion and sensitivity. We were very pleased and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Carlie to anyone. - Renie Heywood
Home in Port Colborne | May 2024
As long time friends of Carlie's, we've seen her grow and develop as a realtor over her career. When it came time for us to shop around, it was a no brainer that she was our choice. Shopping with us was not a linear process, we started in 2017 but didn't end up purchasing with Carlie until 2024. Carlie is always patient, kind but most importantly honest. When it came to looking at homes, knowing our family and our dreams, she often said "this just isn't the right house for you guys and here's the reason why". It means the world to us to shop with someone who knows you! When it came to listing our house, this was a world wind but Carlie made it happen. From the time we put an offer in on a house to the time we moved out of our home was a total of 24 days, selling our house with 1 day on the market! All of this would not have been possible without the help of a knowledgable realtor who was able to help us with the in's and out's of paperwork, legalities, lawyer recommendations and of course her amazing marketing skills. Thank you for all your help, we couldn't have imagined doing it with anyone else! - Amanda Wilcox
Home in Port Colborne | Jun 2024
We worked with Carlie to buy our first home 5 years ago and we worked with her again to sell and buy a bigger home for our growing family. 10 out of 10, would recommend to anyone in the Niagara Region. - Ian McMillan
Home Purchase in Port Colborne | Jun 2024
What can I say about Carlie! When I first met Carlie, she was our landlord. We rented from her for a few years and she was the best landlord we’d ever had. When we decided it was time to buy, Carlie was there for us, through it all. She helped us find something perfect for our very specific needs & wants. Carlie was nothing but honest, supportive and informative and she made this process so much easier. Should we ever decide to buy a house again, it was only ever be with her. She’s the kindest, most genuine person and we couldn’t have asked for a better realtor. - Jayme dodge
Home Purchase in Port Colborne | Nov 2023
My relationship with Carlie began just shy of a decade ago as my Landlord. I knew then when my time came to purchase a house I would be using Carlie as my realtor without question. Since day 1, Carlie has been nothing short of amazing. She is approachable, attentive, professional, confident, knowledgeable in all areas, caring and so much more. Carlie responds quickly to messages, emails, phone calls. That being said, when away from the office her clients are aware ASAP and she will have another professional lined up in her absence. Her team- just as amazing as she is!! Carlie wants a dream home scenario for all her clients. I was running thin on patience, as one does when looking for a home, and Carlie remained calm through my madness and brought my patience back to earth…and thus, I purchased my first home! Carlie is a wonderful person to work with, I cannot recommend her enough! If you are in the market to sell or buy, please give my girl a call. You will not be disappointed. Thanks Carlie 💞 - Tori Strohak
Home in Port Colborne | Jun 2024
We used Carlie to buy our first home and to sell/buy our second. Carlie has an amazing balance of being non-judgemental and understanding while also being a "straight shooter" that lays out options, information, and facts in an easy to understand way. Her approach really empowered us every step of the way, and every professional she recommended along the way was truly spectacular which made it even better. Would recommend her to anyone. Thanks Carlie! - Shauna
We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor in Carlie Smith, to help sell my husband’s family home. From the very beginning, the level of care, professionalism, and dedication was outstanding. The marketing was incredibly well done — such creative videos and beautiful photos truly showcased the home in the best possible way and helped make the entire listing stand out. Communication was always excellent. Every question or concern was answered quickly (day or night), and we always felt informed and supported throughout the process. We also really appreciated the honest advice and guidance every step of the way. There was never any pressure — just thoughtful recommendations, helpful information, and genuine support to help us make the best decisions. What truly sets Carlie apart is how much she genuinely cares about her clients. What meant the most to us was the patience, kindness, and understanding shown to my elderly mother-in-law. Selling a longtime family home can be emotional, and she handled every interaction with such compassion and respect. She also goes above and beyond by hosting thoughtful client events and even dropping off little goodie bags from time to time — such a personal touch that makes you feel valued and appreciated. It’s clear she is passionate about what she does and about building real relationships with her clients. We are so grateful for all the hard work and would highly recommend Carlie to anyone looking for a realtor who truly cares. - Elisa and Richard Meyden