Pro Agents
Pro agents have made a commitment to a higher standard of service.
- Ask every client to rate their service.
- Answer every text, call, and email promptly.
They've also proven they have the expertise from a wide variety of successful clients.
Plus Agents
Plus agents have paid for extra features on their account. Buying any kind of subscription does not impact the rankings in any way. Agents must prove their success at the Plus level before they get the opportunity to qualify for Pro.
Key Stats
Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 5 times
41 reviews in 8 cities and 6 neighbourhoods.
1st in Welland, ON - 25 Reviews
4th in St Catharines, ON - 4 Reviews
3rd in Port Colborne, ON - 4 Reviews
4th in Haldimand, ON - 2 Reviews
5th in Fort Erie, ON - 2 Reviews
1st in Thorold, ON - 2 Reviews
4th in Fonthill, ON - 1 Reviews
29th in Niagara Falls, ON - 1 Reviews
Track Record
#1 in Welland, ON - 2025
Rating Summary
| Overall Rating |
|
| Knowledgeability Rating |
|
| Professionalism Rating |
|
| Responsiveness Rating |
|
| Usefulness of Website |
|
| Value of Service |
|
| Reach & Lead Generation |
|
| Home Prep & Staging Advice |
|
| Success Ratio | 100 % |
| Recommend Ratio | 100 % |
| Response Rate | 98 % |
In Carly's Own Words:
Contact
Home Sale in Welland | Apr 2026
Our family cannot express how grateful we were to have Carly with us during this journey. While emotional we could not have asked for better. She offered support and care with every step of this process. - Cheryl
Home Sale in Western Hill, St Catharines | Mar 2026
Carly was absolutely amazing during the entire process of selling my house. In such a difficult market for sellers, Carly was able to work her magic and place that SOLD sign on the lawn!!!! From the property listing, videos and marketing strategies, to the way she reviewed the current state of the housing market….I was so impressed. Carly took on the challenging housing market with a smile and a positive attitude and she never gave up on my house!!!!! She was so professional and I love that she was able to understand my situation on a personal level as well. She has a lot of experience as a real estate agent and I’m so grateful that I had the chance to work with her. I give Carly a 10/10. - Cleon
Home Sale in Port Colborne | May 2026
I highly recommend Carly . She is very personable, knowledgeable and became part of our family. She explains things and makes the whole selling process so smooth and non stressful. From her professional photos, marketing strategies and all her knowledge she is truly the best real estate agent around. If you are looking to buy or sell , I highly recommend her as she will get your house sold quickly and for a fair market price . Thank you so much Carly for all your hard work and making this a stress free experience. - Lois Lochhead
Home Purchase in Welland | Mar 2026
I cannot say enough good things about Carly. All of our interactions with her were so professional and friendly. She was warm and welcoming. As first time homebuyers, she provided answers to questions we didn’t even know to ask. She responded quickly to all of our queries and consistently reached out with updates. She earned our trust with all of her actions. - Susan
Home Sale in Fort Erie | Jan 2026
After just ten days on the market Carly not only got me a closed deal but her knowledge and persistence got me over asking price !! Knowing what we know about the current market I am ecstatic about the outcome and I am so grateful for her hard work and patience through this process. Anyone would be lucky to have Carly represent them. She not only helps you home...she fights for you and helps make these hard decisions so much easier and content to live with ! - Stephanie
Home Sale in Welland | Dec 2025
Carly was wonderful to work with. Always available when needed. Very patient with explaining the various stages throughout the process. She knows that selling a home is not just a financial transaction, but also an emotional one, and supports the client on both fronts. - Anna
Home in Welland | Nov 2025
I’ve worked with Carly for years, and she’s always been exceptional! She sold my house quickly and also helped me find the perfect new home. Carly is professional, reliable, and truly cares about her clients. I couldn’t recommend her more highly! - Jon
Home in Welland | Oct 2025
Carly has been nothing short of incredible. Her knowledge of the market, region, and the buying/selling process is a resource every buyer/seller should have. Carly goes the extra mile for her clients, and we sure appreciated her patience through the selection process, as well as a sale in a challenging market. - Justin
Other reviews for Home in Welland | Oct 2025
Carly was a top notch agent from start to finish. She is very knowledgable, professional and dependable. Super down to earth and friendly as well. I would 100% recommend Carly to my family and friends! - Lori
Home Sale in Thorold | Oct 2025
Carly was very professional and knowledgable from the start. She was able to successfully sell our home in a short period, compared to our previous agent who had us listed for over 6 months. Her dedication to her clients is amazing and we can't recommend her enough. - Denis & Gord W.
Home in Port Colborne | May 2023
Carly was always professional, knowledgeable and honest. Even when it took some time to sell our home (not a great market at the time) she was there to make sure we found the prefect home for my family and I. - Bryan Wessel
Home in Welland | Oct 2023
Carly was so helpful with the sale of my house through a difficult time and then again when when I purchased my own home and starting a new chapter in my life. Amazing realtor. Will definitely call on her again and recommend to everyone! - Sarah
Home Purchase in Welland | Jun 2019
Carly is extremely knowledgeable and has always provided exceptional services. She follows up with you for the following years after the transaction with the most unique mail gifts, its quite wonderful. - Andrea Cormier
Home in Welland | Apr 2020
Stellar realtor! Would highly recommend and always do. Loved working with Carly and will continue to do so. She is professional and incredibly knowledgeable. Carly cares tremendously about her clients needs and is willing to go to bat for them. - Tracy
Home in Welland | Jan 2018
Carly is the best agent I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with. She was always there through every part of the buying and selling process and beyond. She always makes herself available to answer any questions I have, even years later. She really cares about her clients and it shows in everything she does! - Nicole
Home in Grantham, St Catharines | Aug 2016
Carly is a great Realtor. She helped us sell our home and buy our new one. She also helped us sell our friend's home. She knows her stuff and genuinely cares about her clients. She is very thoughtful. We consider her part of our family. - Diane Lutomsky
Home in Welland | Mar 2022
Carly is amazing! She is patient and kind and found exactly what I was looking for! I have bought and sold with Carly and both transactions were smooth. I would highly recommend Carly! - Cathy
Home in Welland | Mar 2026
We would highly recommend Carly she is very professional and a caring person. She treats all her clients like family . She also keeps in contact with you well after you sell or buy your house. - Marie-Louise Rodrigue
Home Purchase in York-Haig, St Catharines | Jul 2011
Carly subsequently helped us sell that house and purchase another one. If you want the best, then Carly is the go-to person. In addition, she is a wonderful human being with a very large heart. She helps in the community as well as doing a winning job for her clients. - Diane
Home in Welland | Jun 2022
Carly is an amazing agent. She was so helpful with my husband and I when we were in the process of selling our house and even house hunting. She always made time for us and would do her research well! She even goes above and beyond after the sale was done! - Emily
Home Sale in Welland | Mar 2025
I can’t say enough good things about Carly. She recently sold two houses for me — both in record time — and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. From start to finish, she was professional, kind, honest, and incredibly reliable. Carly is a fantastic communicator, always keeping me updated and answering any questions promptly and clearly. She truly goes above and beyond for her clients, handling every detail with care and making sure nothing falls through the cracks. I always felt she had my best interests at heart, and her combination of expertise, market knowledge, and genuine kindness made her a pleasure to work with. I would highly recommend Carly to anyone looking to buy or sell a home, and I will very likely work with her again in the future. She’s the kind of real estate agent who turns what can be a stressful experience into something positive and even enjoyable. - Wendy
Townhome Purchase in Welland | Nov 2019
When you buy a house with Carly, you don’t just get a new home, you also gain a friend for life. Carly is the most caring and kind agent you will ever work with. She really goes the extra mile to know her clients’ needs, and patiently guided me into the next chapter of my life. I value Carly’s continued support and recommend her to all my friends and family. - Linda
Home Sale in Thorold | Jul 2020
Carly is professional, caring, patient but above all honest. Carly is by far the best realtor we ever had.we have recommended Carly to friends and family members. We felt comfortable with Carly from the first time we met her at an open house she was holding.I especially liked the fact that she never rushed us. - Josephine
Home in Merritton, St Catharines | Mar 2024
I have had the absolute pleasure of utilizing Carly's talents 7 times in the last 10+ years. I trust her implicitly and wouldn't consider enlisting the services of anyone else! - Kate
Home Purchase in Welland | Aug 2020
We met Carly Corinthos at one of her open houses, and as soon as we left, we looked at each other and said, “We need to contact her.” From that moment on, Carly proved to be incredibly knowledgeable, kind, and informative. As first-time homebuyers with a long list of requirements, we were stepping into unfamiliar territory, but Carly guided us through every step with patience, clarity, and confidence. What truly sets Carly apart is how genuine she is. She’s not just a real estate agent, she’s someone who truly has your best interest at heart. We always felt like she was advocating for us, never pushing, always listening, and consistently going above and beyond to make sure we felt informed and supported. Thanks to her expertise and dedication, we successfully purchased our first home in Welland during COVID, even helping us win a very competitive bidding war. Carly is an essential part of our journey, and we’re deeply grateful to have had her in our corner. - Kayla & Joe
Home in Welland | Nov 2014
Transactions with Carly feels more like dealing with a friend and not a realtor. Carly goes above and beyond for her clients. She is always available and gives great advice. Thank you Carly for all of your help! - Lana
Home Purchase in Niagara Falls | Apr 2019
I have used Carly several times and all my transactions have gone faster than I expected and with little to no stress .She is extremely knowledgeable regarding the market , therefore getting the highest value for my asset. I look forward to working with Carly for my next transaction. - Clodette
Home in Port Colborne | Jul 2021
Carly was fabulous to work with. She made us super comfortable, was super patient when explaining the process, gave advice based on what was best for us, and really guided us through the process. Carly was like our own cheerleader. We felt super comfortable with her and knew she was in our corner. She maintains regular contact, letting us know that she is thinking of us. She makes us want to sell and buy again just to be able to work that closely with her again. Carly truly went above and beyond and made the interaction so seamless. We are forever grateful to have her in our lives. - Danielle
Home Sale in Welland | Jul 2023
Positively wonderful every step of the way ! I will use Carly again and send any friends or family to her because of attention to detail. Carly is a delight to work with ! - Karyn
Home Purchase in Welland | Dec 2018
Carly helped me navigate through a hard time in my life. She was knowledgable, kind and understanding. She had me and my family's interest at heart. We had a unusual situation and She was more then accomadating. - Marie-Josee
Home Purchase in Dunnville, Haldimand | May 2019
Fantastic experience! My home purchase was easy! Carly's expertise and knowledge was invaluable! She rises above the crowd on customer service! I would recommend her to anyone, young or old, first home or last, she knows what you need and makes is simple for you. - Carrie
Home Purchase in Welland | Sep 2018
Very knowledgeable and patient with us as first time home buyers who didn’t know what to expect. When we do decide to sell and move into another home, we will be using Carly again. - Sarah
Home in Welland | Jun 2017
Carly is fantastic. Sold my old home and got us this new home. I am currently in the process of selling and buying again. Carly is the FIRST person I sought out. No one else will do for me, she is professional, patient in finding the right move for me and she really listens to her client. There is no one better in my opinion. - Diane
Condo Sale in Welland | Aug 2025
Carly is a great agent and truly cares about finding you the right place to call home. I have used her several times and am thankful to have found someone who really cares about you and your happiness. She is also very knowledgably , personable and thorough . - June
Home in Welland | Sep 2025
I 100% recommend Carly as a Real Estate Agent. A friend referred Carly and she went above and beyond. Carly was great, with every knowlegable communication to recommendations for prepping my house forsale and with a wonderful picture and video listing to my SOLD house in 4 days. Carly was available any day I had a question or when I needed to go look at so many lovely homes for me to purchase. Carly had my best interest at heart, making sacrifices along the way to ensure that I got exactly the perfect house to suit my family's and my needs. If you are selling or buying a home, Carly will make your journey easier and a pleasure. - Denise Comfort
Home Sale in Welland | May 2025
Carly was helpful, personable and knowledgable. She was attentive and offered advice throughout the whole process. Selling my parents home was about getting the right buyer and Carly made that happen. We would without hesitation recommend her to sell your home and/or find the perfect home to buy. - Sondi
Home in Port Colborne | Aug 2024
Very pleased with the service Carly gave us with both selling our home and buying another. She went over and above and we would not hesitate to use her again! - Lana
Home Purchase in Fonthill | Feb 2025
Carly went above and beyond in every step of the process. Her patience and knowledge were endless throughout the entire process! I couldn't have picked a better agent to serve me throughout the experience! - Sarah
Home Purchase in Welland | Oct 2025
Carly has been my exclusive agent for several years now and I trust her with all my real estate needs. Whether it is buying or selling a home, she is very knowledgeable and does everything she can to make sure you understand all of your options. - Clark
Home Purchase in Welland | Sep 2025
It was a pleasure to work with Carly. Her market knowledge and negotiating skills enabled me to get the home at a great price point. She was very attentive and a consummate professional throughout the whole process. I look forward to working with her on any future property purchases. - Rick Kukalis
Home in Fort Erie | Jul 2025
Carly Corinthos is a consumate professional who provided the information and support that I required to make good decisions in both purchasing and selling my home. This was accomplished totally without pressure and she was always prompt on following up on all my requests and queries. Her help and guidance was very much appreciated and she also made the paperwork as simple as it could be. - Dejan Ristic
All our questions were quickly and professionally answered. Carly helped our fear/anxiety and kept us aware of all transactions . Carly basically took care of the purchase and the seller told us she had more help from Carly than her realtor! - Susan and Michael Walker