Pro Agents
Pro agents have made a commitment to a higher standard of service.
- Ask every client to rate their service.
- Answer every text, call, and email promptly.
They've also proven they have the expertise from a wide variety of successful clients.
Plus Agents
Plus agents have paid for extra features on their account. Buying any kind of subscription does not impact the rankings in any way. Agents must prove their success at the Plus level before they get the opportunity to qualify for Pro.
Key Stats
Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 5 times
15 reviews in 6 cities and 5 neighbourhoods.
2nd in Caledon, ON - 10 Reviews
1st in Bolton, ON - 1 Reviews
1st in Magnetawan, ON - 1 Reviews
22nd in Halton Hills, ON - 1 Reviews
87th in Burlington, ON - 1 Reviews
91st in Cambridge, ON - 1 Reviews
Rating Summary
| Overall Rating |
|
| Knowledgeability Rating |
|
| Professionalism Rating |
|
| Responsiveness Rating |
|
| Usefulness of Website |
|
| Value of Service |
|
| Reach & Lead Generation |
|
| Home Prep & Staging Advice |
|
| Success Ratio | 92 % |
| Recommend Ratio | 100 % |
| Response Rate | 93 % |
In Hilary's Own Words:
Contact
Home Purchase in Caledon | Oct 2025
Hilary went above and beyond for us! They were incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and dedicated — even traveling all the way up to Muskoka to help us find the perfect place. Their communication was excellent, and their experience made the whole process seamless and enjoyable. We truly appreciated their commitment and can’t recommend Hilary highly enough - Hayden Hooker
Home Purchase in Caledon East, Caledon | Sep 2025
I highly recommend Hilary as an honest, trustworthy, and hard working agent. From our first meeting, she consistently impressed me with her positive energy, market knowledge, and clear communication. She patiently guided my search across Caledon, Erin and Mono - from raw land opportunities to estate homes on large acreages. She expertly navigated a complicated offer situation and I couldn't be happier with the outcome - my dream home in the country. Thanks Hilary! - Trevor
Condo Purchase in Aldershot Central, Burlington | Aug 2025
Hillary Matthew’s helped me with furnishing my condo as seen in the pictures attached. The whole process of buying a condo is unnerving as there is so much paperwork to complete and so many calls with the bank manager and the lawyers needed. Especially if you are a first time home buyer, the process takes up all the time. By the day it was time for me to move in to my new condo, I had used up the last bit of my mental reserve in packing my belongings and completing the move to my new condo. Hillary helped me with identifying the furniture and layouts that would work in my condo and gave me a to do list of things to buy and I followed that verbatim and I love how my condo looks and feels now. She was very thoughtful in picking the right furniture and layouts to fit into the available space and I am loving how this condo has become a livable home. I would highly recommend her services to anyone looking to furnish their new house and needing a second opinion on how to setup the furniture in their new home. - Nirav Desai
Condo Purchase in Downtown Cambridge, Cambridge | Aug 2025
Recently bought a new condominium with the help of hilary as my realtor and I can't tell you how satisfied I am with the results. Very responsive, got things setup ahead of time, provides proper information, hard working and all around positive attitude. - Izak
Home Sale in Bolton, Caledon | Sep 2024
Hilary was incredible to work with, with our home in Caledon! She is very honest, direct, knowledgeable, and promptly returns phone calls and emails. Anytime we had questions, she was very diligent and thorough when providing us with answers. She is a true professional that really cares about helping you make the best decision regarding your home. I strongly recommend contacting Hilary if you are in need of a realtor! - George
Condo Transaction in Bolton, Caledon | Jul 2024
Home Purchase in Bolton, Caledon | Aug 2023
I’ve worked with Hilary on 7 properties buying and selling, and several renovation projects from investment properties to my personal homes. I have always appreciated her work ethic, knowledge and advice. I will continue to use Hilary in the future and would not hesitate to recommend her. - Gerald
Home Sale in Georgetown, Halton Hills | Apr 2024
It was our good fortune to have Hilary Matthews as our agent. Hilary has a very strong work ethic and an amazing eye for detail. Her skills in marketing, paperwork, and negotiating delivered a stress-free experience for which we were very grateful. All of which resulted in a full price offer within days of listing. We have no hesitation in recommending Hilary Matthews to anyone looking for a calm and knowledgeable real estate agent who puts her clients first. - Bob and Chris
Land Purchase in Magnetawan | Jul 2025
Home Transaction in Bolton, Caledon | Nov 2025
Home Sale in Caledon | Aug 2025
Hilary was unfailingly helpful, with many great recommendations. She came over numerous times to help with things, even moving furniture and household items, as well as lending staging items, researching contractors, getting quotes for small jobs that needed doing, supervising work while I was away…essentially, she was a godsend. Very highly recommend her - no-one could have done more. - Susan
Home Purchase in Bolton | May 2024
Home Transaction in Bolton, Caledon | Nov 2024
Hilary was incredible in helping us find our new home! She suggested properties that we may not have thought to go and see, and helped with comparisons in the area. If we had any questions she was very quick to respond. With the market as it is now, a slow response could you mean you loose the opportunity to find your perfect home, and whenever we asked Hilary about a property we liked in the Caledon area she always responded quickly and with beneficial information about the property. Her dedication to helping people find their perfect fit is incredible with seeing as many places as it took until we found the right one - all thanks to her help. She graciously accommodated us with arranging viewings and walkthroughs that work with our schedules. She was professional, efficient and thorough; we will be choosing her as our representative for anything real-estate related in future. My husband and I fully and whole-heartedly recommend her - she is truly outstanding in her field! - Andrea
Really love working with Hilary in the Caledon Real Estate market. She's also got a great team of contractors behind her to help with prepping or revitalizing a home before or after a sale. I would absolutely recommend her. - Amanda