Key Stats

Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 2 times

14 reviews in 4 cities and 5 neighbourhoods.

5th in Barrie, ON - 11 Reviews

418th in Toronto, ON - 1 Reviews

5th in Wasaga Beach, ON - 1 Reviews

8th in Orillia, ON - 1 Reviews

More

Rating Summary

Overall Rating
4.99
Knowledgeability Rating
5.00
Professionalism Rating
5.00
Responsiveness Rating
5.00
Usefulness of Website
4.93
Value of Service
5.00
Reach & Lead Generation
5.00
Home Prep & Staging Advice
5.00
Success Ratio 100 %
Recommend Ratio 100 %
Response Rate 0 %

Contact

Phone Check
Cell Check
Address 374 Huronia Road


5.00

Home in Barrie | Feb 2026

We had a great experience using Peggy and her team for both selling our home and finding our new Condo. They were all over everything right from the start. Our home sold very quickly and we were suddenly left needing to quickly find a solution of where to move with a five week closing and not having our Condo selected. We needed to quickly find a place to move to. Peggy’s team found us a shorter term rental so we could move forward with our Condo search without any pressure. Anything we have needed, they have promptly, professionally handled with constant communication to make sure we always felt well taken care of. The Peggy Hill Team has an excellent marketing presence in our city but their attention to detail is what really impressed us. Going that extra mile is why we strongly recommend using the Peggy Hill Team for your real estate needs. - Tom Bock

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Buying and Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Barrie
Feb 2026
February 2026
5.00

Home Sale in Barrie | Mar 2026

Peggy Hill’s team is incredible! Everyone we’ve come into contact with is extremely knowledgeable, responsive and friendly. We sold our home for the price we wanted and very quickly! - Stacey Bock

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Barrie
Mar 2026
February 2026
5.00

Home Sale in Barrie | Jul 2024

Very professional and helpful team. Worked around my schedule with family. Kept in touch every step of the way to ensure everything went smoothly. Went the extra mile to help find supplies, questions and moving details. Stayed in contact with me even after my move to offer any assistance. Great team - Dawn Miller

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
NO
Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Barrie
Jul 2024
February 2026
4.86

Home in Holly, Barrie | Jan 2026

The Peggy Hill Team was very knowledgeable and helped us with all our home buying and selling needs. I would recommend them to anyone looking to make this important life change. - Connie Miranda

5.00
5.00
5.00
4.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Buying and Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Holly, Barrie
Jan 2026
February 2026
5.00

Home Purchase in Orillia | Sep 2022

I worked with the Peggy Hill Team to purchase my first home. The team made the experience stress free and enjoyable. They provided so much valuable information throughout the whole process. I am very grateful for their help and will always use them for my real-estate needs. Highly highly recommend the Peggy Hill Team! - Jessica Eberlin

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
YES
Buying
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Orillia
Sep 2022
February 2026
5.00

Home Sale in Barrie | Mar 2025

Highly recommend The Peggy Hill Team. Amazing job from start to finish. The online marketing and open houses gave us the exposure we needed to sell this home in a difficult market. - Sherry

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Barrie
Mar 2025
February 2026
5.00

Townhome Sale in Barrie | May 2019

The best Real estate team in the area , gta and simcoe , very good marketing and follow up . Honest and caring , sold my house for top dollars - Mira Lewandowska

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
YES
Selling
Successful
YES
Townhouse
Barrie
May 2019
February 2026
5.00

Home Sale in Allandale Centre, Barrie | Aug 2024

I have used the Peggy Hill Team twice for selling and buying my homes and I would highly recommend them. Excellent service and a pleasure to work with. - Peggy Witzel

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Allandale Centre, Barrie
Aug 2024
February 2026
5.00

Home Purchase in Wasaga Beach | Feb 2025

Very professional and always available to answer questions and help with any issues regarding the sale of our other home which was located in a different area. Kept us advised and up to date with progress on our purchase. Would highly recommend The Peggy Hill team - Sheila Prestidge

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
-
-
Buying
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Wasaga Beach
Feb 2025
February 2026
5.00

Home Purchase in Barrie | May 2024

It was a very nice and easy process for buying. The agent was present and keep us always informed on new listings. We felt always as top priority. We appreciate the service done by Peggy Hill team. - Sebastian Aponte

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Buying
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Barrie
May 2024
February 2026
5.00

Home in Barrie | Jul 2025

Fantastic experience. Expert knowledge and shared the same determination and motivation as my wife and I. Showed us a lot of different houses but understood what we were looking for and really helped us get exactly what we wanted. - Shayne Weatherby

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
YES
Buying and Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Barrie
Jul 2025
February 2026
5.00

Home Purchase in Georgian Drive, Barrie | Sep 2025

Peggy’s team showed us homes in our price range and knew what we were looking for, saving us a lot of time. Was able to accommodate our inspection schedule on short notice. - Pete Fortin

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
NO
Buying
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Georgian Drive, Barrie
Sep 2025
February 2026
5.00

Home Purchase in Grove East, Barrie | Sep 2025

The Peggy Hill Team was incredibly professional. They responded to my questions promptly and intelligently. They sent me information about moving and provided moving materials for us. I would not hesitate to refer them to my friend ms and family members. - Suzanne

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
YES
Buying
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Grove East, Barrie
Sep 2025
February 2026
5.00

Condo Sale in Waterfront Communities-the Island, Toronto | Mar 2022

The Peggy Hill team is the best team and they can successfully sell homes not only in Simcoe County- but also beyond this area. Their team is very professional and has a strong brand reputation, which really helps to sell a home. - Khizar Mir

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
YES
Selling
Successful
YES
Condo / Apartment
Waterfront Communities-the Island, Toronto
Mar 2022
February 2026

Find other Barrie agents.

All profiles and profile information on Rate-My-Agent.com has been provided by users of the site. Rate-My-Agent.com makes no representation as to accuracy of profile information. Specifically, Rate-My-Agent.com and it's owners disclaim any liability relating to the comments, reviews, and ratings posted by users of the website. Rate-My-Agent.com is not attempting to personate any person who's name and/or other identifying information may have been posted on the website.