Pro Agents
Pro agents have made a commitment to a higher standard of service.
- Ask every client to rate their service.
- Answer every text, call, and email promptly.
They've also proven they have the expertise from a wide variety of successful clients.
Plus Agents
Plus agents have paid for extra features on their account. Buying any kind of subscription does not impact the rankings in any way. Agents must prove their success at the Plus level before they get the opportunity to qualify for Pro.
Key Stats
Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 4 times
33 reviews in 7 cities and 13 neighbourhoods.
15th in Mississauga, ON - 20 Reviews
54th in Hamilton, ON - 4 Reviews
193rd in Toronto, ON - 3 Reviews
2nd in Halton Hills, ON - 3 Reviews
65th in Milton, ON - 1 Reviews
17th in Etobicoke, ON - 1 Reviews
57th in Guelph, ON - 1 Reviews
Rating Summary
| Overall Rating |
|
| Knowledgeability Rating |
|
| Professionalism Rating |
|
| Responsiveness Rating |
|
| Usefulness of Website |
|
| Value of Service |
|
| Reach & Lead Generation |
|
| Home Prep & Staging Advice |
|
| Success Ratio | 100 % |
| Recommend Ratio | 100 % |
| Response Rate | 91 % |
In Amy's Own Words:
Contact
Home Purchase in Dundas, Hamilton | Jan 2025
Home Purchase in Hamilton | Apr 2024
Our experience with Amy and her team was outstanding! They were professional, attentive, and truly went above and beyond to make the process smooth and stress-free. Their knowledge of the market and genuine care for our needs made all the difference. We couldn’t be happier with our new home! - Kieran
Home Purchase in Hamilton | Jun 2024
Amy is such an incredible agent to work with. She is not only incredibly kind but she has a vast knowledge of the market for both buying and selling. She has played an integral role in the purchase and renting of my home(s) and I recommend her to everyone I know. - Alex
Home Transaction in Central Erin Mills, Mississauga | Apr 2025
An exceptional, trustworthy and very knowledgeable agent, but more importantly a very genuine and great person. I don't have very good experiences with real estate agents, but I would highly recommend Amy Shugar to all my family and friends. - Omar Sabri
Home Sale in Meadowvale, Mississauga | Jan 2023
Sold Fast at Our Asking Price - Thanks to the exceptional Amy Shugar Team! I couldn’t have asked for a better experience selling my home with Amy Shugar. From start to finish, her expertise, professionalism, and genuine care made a potentially stressful process smooth and successful. She took care of every request I had and went above and beyond to ensure that my house would sell for what I was asking. Some notable shout outs, her home prep / staging / cleaning / carpet crew left my home impeccable, every nook and cranny was cleaned, ensuring that the house showed beautifully. Furthermore, the stunning drone photography; the aerial shots highlighted my property’s features and gave buyers a great impression of what they were getting. Combined with Amy's strategic marketing ability, my home sold quickly at the price that I wanted. What impressed me most was how Amy balanced professionalism with empathy. She listened to my goals / requests, communicated clearly, and worked tirelessly to make the sale happen at my pace. If you want an agent who delivers results while making you feel supported, this is your agent: Amy Shugar. Highly recommend! - Chris
Home in Mississauga | Aug 2019
Amy is a very good agent and goes out of her way to help us - even after the sale was made. She was very helpful at every step of the process - explaining everything and helping us with any questions. would recommend her to anyone buying or selling and also leasing properties. - Brian
Townhome Transaction in Central Erin Mills, Mississauga | Sep 2018
Amy is fantastic. She helped us when we were relocating for personal reasons and got our property listed and continues to help us find tenants. She’s responsive and we know we are in good hands with her and will not use anyone else to help us with our largest asset. - Kamal and Jen Seehra
Home Sale in Oakwood Village, Toronto | Dec 2025
Amy is very professional and kept a strong focus on the issues that mattered while selling our property. She doesn't just follow a script, but considers all details about the objective and situation and focuses resources where they will provide the best benefit. - Adam
Home in Meadowvale, Mississauga | Mar 2023
Amy was very helpful and compassionate during this difficult time for the family. She made each step easier to deal with and was available when I had questions. I would recommend Amy and her team with any sales and purchases. - Michele
Home Sale in Meadowvale, Mississauga | Aug 2024
Amy and her team were incredibly helpful throughout the process of selling our family home. They were sensitive to our needs, very accommodating, and worked hard to make the entire process as smooth and simple as possible. We truly appreciated their support and professionalism - Maria
Townhome Sale in Mississauga | Oct 2025
This is not the first time using Amy for this type of transaction. She is professional, efficient and most of all KIND. She genuinely cares for her customers and strives to achieve the best possible outcome that causes the least amount of stress. Stress is inevitable when selling a home but Amy knows all the answers and never makes you feel like you are asking a dumb question. I would highly recommend her for any real estate needs you might have. She’s the best!! - Stephanie
Home Sale in Meadowvale, Mississauga | Aug 2024
Amy’s priority is that her customers are comfortable and happy with their transactions. She sold our home and guided us through the purchase of our condo. Her service levels are exceptional. We are grateful to have her as our agent and friend. - Janet
Townhome Purchase in Guelph | Aug 2024
Home in Streetsville, Mississauga | Aug 2021
we have used Amy for multiple transactions and properties over the past 9 10 years. Amy is a pro ! We have recommended her and will continue to use her for all types of purchases and sales and even finding and vetting tenants. Amy is good fun to work with as well even through stressful times - Angela
Home in Streetsville, Mississauga | Nov 2016
Amy is fabulous to work with! She is very knowledgeable, quick to respond and incredibly supportive during the process of buying and selling our home. She goes above and beyond. We plan to work with Amy in our next purchase. - Imee
Townhome Sale in Streetsville, Mississauga | Oct 2022
Amy was very professional and direct with what we should realistically expect to selling our property. After closing, our lawyer even commented on her expertise, and he was comparing to the many agents he was used to. - Violetta Wareing
Home in Acton, Halton Hills | Aug 2023
Amy was hands on and helped every step of the way. Always answered her phone and was available. Amy makes difficult seem easy!!! We have used her for friends and family and she has done over seven transactions for all of us! - Karenanne
Home Sale in Meadowvale, Mississauga | Sep 2021
Amy gave us exceptional and professional service. Her attention to detail was outstanding and she made the process of selling our house very easy. She is honest and trustworthy and I would use her for any future real estate services. I would also recommend her to others without hesitation. - Bernie F
Home in Streetsville, Mississauga | May 2018
Amy was amazing. Responsive, always had our backs, honest. We trusted her completely. She also assisted with the purchase of our new home too and our son and daughter in laws properties. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend her - Sarah
Condo Transaction in Mississauga | Nov 2025
I'm incredibly impressed by Amy's exceptional market knowledge and trends. She is always available to answer our questions and keep us updated at every step, which made the stressful process feel smooth and stress free. We couldn't have been happier with the exceptional service. - Yuka
Townhome Purchase in Long Branch, Etobicoke | Dec 2019
Home in Willowridge-Martingrove-Richview, Toronto | Sep 2022
Home in Erindale, Mississauga | Jun 2017
Home in Acton, Halton Hills | May 2024
Finding the right agent was crucial for us, and we were so glad to find someone as patient and dedicated as Amy. She went above and beyond for us at every stage of the process—shopping for our forever home, buying it, selling our old one, and even helping with the move. We've officially found our forever home, but we'll be telling everyone we know who's looking for a house that they have to call Amy! - Melissa
Home Sale in Meadowvale, Mississauga | Aug 2024
As a senior on my own, Amy was always patient kind, knowledgeable and available. She arranged to get rid of unwanted furniture, and set me up with required repair people. All the work she did for me cut down on the stress level associated with moving. I felt like we were partners. - Cathy Richards
Townhome Transaction in Lorne Park, Mississauga | Dec 2024
Townhome in Streetsville, Mississauga | Sep 2023
Home in Georgetown, Halton Hills | Jul 2023
Very professional and accommodating, felt like I was her only client because she was always available and helpful at any time of the day. Amy made selling and buying a smooth transition and stress free. Can't say enough good about Amy, simply amazing. - Michelle
Condo Sale in North York, Toronto | Apr 2021
Amy was always a pleasure to work with. She was professional, approachable, patient, flexible, and very experienced. We actually used her service three times, once selling a condo and twice purchasing a condo and she has been proven to be the most reliable and effective real estate agent for our needs. I have no hesitation in recommending her to any potential buyers or sellers and in working with her in our future real estate transactions. - Chiya
Home Sale in Milton | Aug 2025
Amy is so dedicated to her clients! She’s incredibly thorough, compassionate and committed! I would recommend her and use her again. She truly went above and beyond. Amy’s attention to detail, timely delivery is next level. - Seanna Swayne
Home Purchase in Hamilton | Dec 2024
Home Sale in Streetsville, Mississauga | Jun 2025
Amy is very knowledgeable about selling homes in our area. Amy was very supportive and was helpful in getting our house ready to be moved for closing. She went above and beyond calling to make sure our family was OK at all times. - Diana
Other reviews for Home Sale in Streetsville, Mississauga | Jun 2025
Amy is very knowledgeable about selling homes in our area. Amy was very supportive and was helpful in getting our house ready to be moved for closing. She went above and beyond calling to make sure our family was OK at all times. - Diana
Amy is very knowledgeable about real estate in our neighbourhood. Amy contacted us with updates and was supportive to our family's needs. Can't say enough how she got us ready for our move. - Diana
Amy and her team are exceptional! Although we were navigating through this difficult market, Amy was on top of all changes in pricing and demands of buyers. Staging and photography were beautifully done to highlight all of our houses best features! We have engaged Amy for two sales and 3 purchases and will continue to use her in the future. - Tracy Tremblett