Best St Catharines Real Estate Agents — Ranked by 189 Verified Reviews | August 2026
Selling or buying? See the same agents ranked by sellers’ reviews or buyers’ reviews.
The same St Catharines agents, ranked by side
Every review records whether the client was buying or selling, so the same agents can be scored one side at a time.
- Best listing agents in St Catharines — 5 agents ranked on 37 reviews from people who sold
- Best buyer’s agents in St Catharines — 10 agents ranked on 81 reviews from people who bought
Hire the Right Real Estate Agent
If you want to avoid the hassle of reading a ton of reviews, sending many messages, and doing endless interviews - let us find the best real estate agent for your unique scenario. Fill out our short Agent Matching Quiz and we'll match you with a pre-screened, experienced, and top-rated agent who's performance is tracked. These agents don't work for us and this service is 100% free, meaning there is no cost or obligation to work with the agent we find you. It will save you hours of researching and interviewing agents.
I'm looking for a...
Top Realtor Reviews of the Best Real Estate Agents in St Catharines
Find the best Realtors in Saint Catharines, Ontario and area. Buyer's agents and seller's agents for every transaction type can be reviewed on Rate-My-Agent.com. If you want help selecting the right agent to help you buy your next place or list your property for sale, take 30 seconds to fill out our easy quiz and we'll recommend the right agent for your situation. There is no obligation to work with the recommended agent and there's no cost to you.
All Realtors in St Catharines are members of the Niagara Association of REALTORS. To file a formal complaint against an agent or brokerage, follow the process at the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO).
Top St Catharines neighbourhoods with rated agents include: York-Haig, Grantham, Merritton, Lakeport, Queenston.
Nearby cities: Niagara Falls, Welland, Port Colborne, Fonthill, Niagara on the Lake, Niagara, Beamsville.
St Catharines, ON Real Estate Agent Rating Stats
| Number of Real Estate Agents | 109 |
| Reviews on File | 189 |
| Real Estate Agents with 5-Star Reviews | 85.71% |
| Ratings of 3 Stars or Lower | 10 |
| Success Rate | 91.53% |
| Average Overall Rating | 4.78 |
| Average Knowledgeability Rating | 4.81 |
| Average Professionalism Rating | 4.79 |
| Average Responsiveness Rating | 4.79 |
| Average Usefulness of Website | 4.81 |
| Average Value of Service | 4.90 |
| Average Marketing Reach & Lead Generation | 4.89 |
| Average Home Prep & Staging Advice | 4.88 |
Last Updated: August 9, 2026