Nicole Caldwell
86% Response Rate
Pro Agents
Pro agents have made a commitment to a higher standard of service.
- Ask every client to rate their service.
- Answer every text, call, and email promptly.
They've also proven they have the expertise from a wide variety of successful clients.
Plus Agents
Plus agents have paid for extra features on their account. Buying any kind of subscription does not impact the rankings in any way. Agents must prove their success at the Plus level before they get the opportunity to qualify for Pro.
Key Stats
Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 2 times
7 reviews in 5 cities and 6 neighbourhoods.
3rd in Oak Bay, BC - 1 Reviews
135th in Victoria, BC - 2 Reviews
56th in Saanich, BC - 2 Reviews
22nd in Ladysmith, BC - 1 Reviews
18th in Sidney, BC - 1 Reviews
Rating Summary
| Overall Rating |
|
| Knowledgeability Rating |
|
| Professionalism Rating |
|
| Responsiveness Rating |
|
| Usefulness of Website |
|
| Value of Service |
|
| Reach & Lead Generation |
|
| Home Prep & Staging Advice |
|
| Success Ratio | 100 % |
| Recommend Ratio | 100 % |
| Response Rate | 86 % |
Contact
Condo Purchase in Sidney North West, Sidney | Jan 2026
We're new to BC, so we relied heavily on Nicole for knowledge of the area and the market. She listened to what we wanted, never pushed us in other directions, and worked hard to help us and to answer all our questions. She was always well-prepared, personable, professional, and in every way a pleasure to work with. We wouldn't hesitate to trust our next home purchase to Nicole. - Kris and Paul Leathers
Townhome in Victoria West, Victoria | Dec 2025
Nicole was a great realtor for the buying and selling of my townhouse in Victoria, BC. She was patient, well prepared, and supportive when I looked at and bought my townhouse, and equally well prepared, attentive, and professional when selling it again. She knows the market and responds quickly to questions. - Kristin
Home Sale in Rockland, Victoria | Dec 2025
Nicole went above and beyond for the sale of an old house that needed some TLC in the new buyers hands. Helpful in every way with a willingness to go beyond in getting the house prepared for the sale and closing. Highly recommended for any future business! - Cathryn
Home Purchase in Z3 Ladysmith, Ladysmith | Sep 2025
We were relocating to the area and Nicole was recommended to us by our out of town agent. Nicole made the process very easy and she was available to show us around anytime. She had knowledge on the different areas and helped us find the perfect location. Even things like finding recommendations for inspectors and other professionals, she was very helpful. I highly recommend Nicole for buying and selling any property. - Ashley S
Home Purchase in Victoria, Saanich | Jul 2024
Nicole Caldwell is a Fantastic Agent; very punctual, very knowledgeable, and accommodating. I would recommend her above and beyond any others in the business. Be it for buying or selling. - Velma Sproul
Home Purchase in Victoria, Saanich | Mar 2025
Extremely patient, well prepared , knowledgeable about the individual community differences in the region,quick to respond to any question and to research information for us as looking from out of town. We were looking for very specific property that would fit family co ownership and multi generation opportunity. Nicole understood our individual needs , and gave us time to explore many options . She seems to love what she does and genuinely cares about the outcome for her clients. - Donna Hay
My daughter and I were fortunate to work with Nicole Caldwell during our search for a condominium in Victoria, BC, and we cannot recommend her highly enough. Nicole showed us many properties and demonstrated remarkable patience, professionalism, and dedication. She was always punctual, courteous, knowledgeable, and exceptionally well prepared. What truly set Nicole apart was her willingness to go above and beyond. She never pressured us and never offered unnecessary advice, but whenever we had questions, her answers were thoughtful, detailed, and informed by a level of expertise that extended well beyond what one would normally expect from a real estate agent. Her understanding of the strata issues, property conditions, and the practical realities of home ownership proved invaluable. Throughout the entire process, Nicole worked tirelessly on our behalf. She paid close attention to every detail, responded promptly, and consistently put our interests first. We always felt respected, supported, and confident that we were receiving honest and professional guidance. Having dealt with several real estate agents over the course of my life, I can say without hesitation that Nicole Caldwell is the finest real estate professional I have ever worked with. Her integrity, diligence, knowledge, and commitment to her clients are truly exceptional. If there were a Realtor of the Year award based solely on client service, professionalism, and dedication, Nicole would be a deserving candidate. My daughter and I are deeply grateful for her assistance and would recommend her without reservation to anyone buying or selling a home in Victoria. Thank you, Nicole, for helping us find the right home and for making what can often be a stressful process a positive and successful experience. - Iga and Emily Speur