Pro Agents
Pro agents have made a commitment to a higher standard of service.
- Ask every client to rate their service.
- Answer every text, call, and email promptly.
They've also proven they have the expertise from a wide variety of successful clients.
Plus Agents
Plus agents have paid for extra features on their account. Buying any kind of subscription does not impact the rankings in any way. Agents must prove their success at the Plus level before they get the opportunity to qualify for Pro.
Key Stats
Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 8 times
16 reviews in 11 cities and 8 neighbourhoods.
5th in Haldimand, ON - 3 Reviews
21st in Woodstock, ON - 2 Reviews
115th in Brantford, ON - 2 Reviews
2nd in Hagersville, ON - 1 Reviews
7th in Aylmer, ON - 1 Reviews
9th in Port Colborne, ON - 1 Reviews
13th in Tillsonburg, ON - 1 Reviews
105th in Windsor, ON - 1 Reviews
17th in Simcoe, ON - 1 Reviews
6th in Niagara, ON - 1 Reviews
13th in Norfolk County, ON - 1 Reviews
Rating Summary
| Overall Rating |
|
| Knowledgeability Rating |
|
| Professionalism Rating |
|
| Responsiveness Rating |
|
| Usefulness of Website |
|
| Value of Service |
|
| Reach & Lead Generation |
|
| Home Prep & Staging Advice |
|
| Success Ratio | 100 % |
| Recommend Ratio | 100 % |
| Response Rate | 82 % |
In Peter's Own Words:
Contact
Home Sale in Wellandport, Port Colborne | Apr 2025
Very Good and knowledgeable. Has the understanding of the market and needs of clients..continuing updates with market conditions. Very well stagged house for viewing excellent marketing skills. - Gino Costabile
Home Purchase in Aylmer | Nov 2025
Peter is great. So glad we found him. Peter made himself readily available to us. He is extremely knowledgeable and very patient with many questions. We would gladly recommend him to anyone. - Luana
Home Purchase in Tillsonburg | Nov 2025
he did a great job with the showings plus he kept showing properties that we were interested in and gave us all the information that we needed to make a solid decision on what to buy at the right price. We would recommend him to anyone buying or selling - Ken
Other reviews for Home Purchase in Tillsonburg | Nov 2025
Peter did a great job he is very informative about the Real Estate market and was willing to show us all the properties that we were interested in plus he helped with comparative properties and we got a great deal - Kenneth Gordon
Townhome Purchase in Hagersville | Nov 2025
Peter was an excellent agent. He showed me many homes. Pointed out things I wouldn't have thought of. Helped me find a mortgage broker. Very happy with his professionalism. - Chris Halliday
Townhome Purchase in Tavistock, Woodstock | Jun 2024
I was referred to Peter by the agency as I was looking for a home they had listed by another realtor. I was extremely pleased with his service and found him to go above and beyond my expectations. Anytime I had questions he would immediately contact me and provide me with the information I needed. I would definitely recommend Peter Costabile and use his Agency for future realtor needs. - Sharon Flynn
Home Purchase in Brantford | Dec 2023
Peter was always available to ask questions or help out. We had already narrowed our search but needed a buyers agent. I would suggest he provide a simple checklist of the standard steps of purchasing a house and who the primary parties are as the process is unclear to the average client. This would have increased my rating for him and reduced our stress level. Additionally, a who's who list of local contractors and service providers is a nice thing to add for clients moving into the area. Website link or paper copy. - Rod Hunt
Home Purchase in Walsingham, Norfolk County | Dec 2023
Peter is a very helpful and knowledgeable person to work with. We felt very comfortable with his opinion on house values, locations etc.we will definitely recommend him to anyone and will use him in the future. - Doug caswell
Home in Cayuga, Haldimand | Dec 2023
Home Purchase in Niagara, ON | Apr 2022
Peter was an absolute star! He was was able to accommodate whenever needed! He would be in constant communication with me even if it was on weekends and evenings. He actively searched for what I was looking for until I found the right cottage! He ensured that it included absolutely everything I wanted and assured that it was the right purchase. Peter is more than a realtor. He will go above and beyond for you and he will become a life long friend. He is engaging and very positive! I have not only gained a realtor but a friend! Thank you for all you did! I would recommend him to all my family and friends! Can’t wait to see what is next! - Sara Costa
Home Purchase in Selkirk, Haldimand, ON | Dec 2021
Peter is absolutely amazing, he is way knowledgeable, knows the area he operates pretty well, way resourceful, I will strongly recommend him rest be assured he will always put your interest first. Thanks a lot Peter. Way to go.😊 - Raj Arora
Home Purchase in South Walkerville, Windsor, ON | Nov 2021
As a first-time home buyer I had done some research beforehand but was really grateful for Peter Costabile! The process went so smoothly and he was an absolute pleasure to work with. He was very knowledgeable about the process and was a great resource. He offered his opinion when I asked and helped me to consider things I hadn’t thought of. I’ll definitely reach out to Peter Costabile in the future and I recommend him to all my friends and family! - Catherine Telan
Home Purchase in Simcoe, ON | Feb 2021
He was absolutely incredible, quick replies, friendly and really takes the time to talk to you and fine listing that have exactly what you're looking for. It was a pleasure working with him and I would definitely recommend him to anyone looking to buy! - Peter Haywood
Home Purchase in Simcoe, Brantford, ON | Feb 2022
Peter was amazing! My boyfriend and I were looking for a home and could not find one and another realtor did not want to help us! But Peter was great! He got us a home. He walked us through everything and told us what we need and told us what to do!! Everyone should go to peter! I’m so truly blessed to get a home and be with my little family. It was the best Christmas gift we could ask for! Thank you so much Peter! I can’t thank you enough for what you did for us. I thought We would never find a house in this market.. but peter found us a house less then a week! Thank you again! - Anna Wright
Home Purchase in Walkerville, Windsor, ON, Canada | Nov 2021
Peter Costabile is the best! He was thorough and professional and great to work with. He kept us apprised about available appointments and always let us know as soon as a new one came on the market. He was honest and forthright- no games. We felt lucky to find Peter Costabile. - Rolly Pamplona
Home Purchase in Downtown, Woodstock, ON | Jan 2022
It was a great pleasure to have such a wonderful and understanding person like Peter. Peter was very good at communicating with Lucia and i , also was very professional on showing of property's. I would recommend Peter's services to anyone. - Joe Faria
Peter had been very prompt at communication and answering all of my questions from the get go, was awesome to consult with an unsure moments and how market is going. Peter used all the social media platforms to advertise my property find the right seller. During the offer presentations, peter demonstrated strong negotiating skills and got us the closest to our asking price during this challenging market. - Anna Obyavin