Sarah Underhill, Toronto, Real Estate Agent

Sarah Underhill

Real Estate Agent

8% Response Rate

Key Stats

Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 1 times

13 reviews in 3 cities and 3 neighbourhoods.

82nd in Toronto, ON - 11 Reviews

90th in Markham, ON - 1 Reviews

41st in Etobicoke, ON - 1 Reviews

Rating Summary

Overall Rating
4.97
Knowledgeability Rating
5.00
Professionalism Rating
5.00
Responsiveness Rating
5.00
Usefulness of Website
5.00
Value of Service
4.92
Reach & Lead Generation
5.00
Home Prep & Staging Advice
4.85
Success Ratio 100 %
Recommend Ratio 100 %
Response Rate 8 %

Contact

Team Solo
Company Re/Max Hallmark Realty
Website Check
Phone Check
Cell Check
Address 170 Merton St


5.00

Home Sale in Mt Pleasant East, Toronto | Aug 2025

From my very first interaction with Sarah I was put at ease. She has extensive knowledge of the market, focused on my priorities, was excellent at expectation setting, and provided guidance and help through the entire process. Sarah is highly responsive, has reliable 3rd party relationships that do excellent work, and is a great problem solver. She kept me on track through the entire process, developed a shrewd pricing stragegy and guided me through a competitive offer process. I highly recommend her as a trusted partner in selling your home. - Krista

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Mt Pleasant East, Toronto
Aug 2025
August 2025
5.00

Condo Purchase in Toronto | May 2025

Sarah is an exceptionally kind and supportive individual who consistently goes above and beyond to ensure the well-being of her clients. She listens attentively to their needs, offering thoughtful advice tailored to their unique situations. Her empathetic nature creates a comforting environment, allowing clients to feel heard and valued. Moreover, Sarah's expertise and insightful guidance empower her clients to make well-informed decisions confidently, paving the way for their personal and professional growth. - Jad Krisht

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
YES
Buying
Successful
YES
Condo / Apartment
Toronto
May 2025
June 2025
5.00

Home Sale in Davisville, Toronto | Jun 2025

I am a huge fan of Sarah. She has sold two homes for me and helped me purchase one, and I can say quite confidently that she is the best Realtor I have ever worked with. Sarah goes way above and beyond when helping you sell your home. She provides invaluable guidance on what to do, offers market comparables, and gives precise pricing advice. Sarah's support doesn't stop there; she helps with decluttering, puts excess items into storage, and stages your home beautifully. Her marketing skills are top-notch, creating clever social video posts and beautiful pamphlets. She also hosts the most amazing and thoughtful open houses, like the time she had little Easter baskets over Easter weekend. If you're looking for a Realtor who truly cares and goes the extra mile, I highly recommend Sarah. - Nicole Cressman

Reply:    Thank you, Nicole, for your very kind words! I have loved working with you on all of our projects. Very happy and excited for you on this next chapter of your life.

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Davisville, Toronto
Jun 2025
May 2025
5.00

Home in Markham | May 2025

Sarah and her team were superb at helping us through the whole process. She especially went above and beyond to help us purchase our future home. Her care to details when staging the home as well was what made our house look so great and sell so fast. - Lucy Santos

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
YES
Buying and Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Markham
May 2025
May 2025
5.00

Home Purchase in Mt Pleasant East, Toronto | Jul 2024

Sarah is simply the best real estate agent we have worked with! She helped my family and I with our move from Montreal to Toronto and made sure we picked a great home in a family friendly neighbourhood. We highly recommend her! - Natasha Rajah & Graeme Moir

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Buying
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Mt Pleasant East, Toronto
Jul 2024
May 2025
5.00

Condo Sale in Banbury-Don Mills, Toronto | Aug 2022

Sarah and her team did an excellent job of assessing, staging and marketing my property within the current market. As a result we sold over asking in three days. I would highly recommend Sarah and her team to anyone looking to sell or purchase a home. She is highly professional, easy to work with and gets stellar results. - Martin Traynor

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Selling
Successful
YES
Condo / Apartment
Banbury-Don Mills, Toronto
Aug 2022
June 2022
5.00

Home Sale in Mt Pleasant East, Toronto | Aug 2022

An awesome agent to work with. Experienced, supportive, and trustworthy. She guided us through the process and made it a pleasant one. Sarah and her team were an absolute pleasure to work with. THANK YOU! - Lina Derkeshli Percy

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
-
Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Mt Pleasant East, Toronto
Aug 2022
June 2022
4.71

Home in Etobicoke, Etobicoke, ON | Jun 2018

We have purchased three properties and sold 1 through Sarah. Sarah is very honest and transparent with her views. Her style of communication is very authentic which helped us immensely. As immigrants all those years ago trying to buy our first property, we were able to to rely on Sarah 100% for good advice. She is never pushy with her POV even when she has a strong one. She balances that with ensuring she gives you more information than you need to help make the right decision. She is like family to us now. - Amit Kaura

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
4.00
5.00
4.00
NO
Buying and Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Etobicoke, Etobicoke, ON
Jun 2018
May 2022
4.86

Home Sale in Mt Pleasant East, Toronto, ON | Jul 2022

I highly recommend Sarah as an agent. She put me at ease throughout the entire process of selling our home while demonstrating the utmost professionalism, sensitivity to our family during the process, responsiveness and knowledge of the market. Sarah is delightful to work with and being able to trust her when she says “I’ve got this” with all the details involved in selling a home, is invaluable. - Krista Nourse

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
4.00
NO
Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Mt Pleasant East, Toronto, ON
Jul 2022
May 2022
5.00

Home in Mt Pleasant East, Toronto, ON | Jun 2022

Sarah has helped me with both buying and selling houses. Her knowledge of the housing market, professionalism and wonderful personality make her a trusted advisor to all her clients. I highly recommend Sarah to anyone looking to purchase or sell their home. - Danelle Parkinson

5.00
5.00
5.00
-
5.00
-
5.00
-
Buying and Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Mt Pleasant East, Toronto, ON
Jun 2022
May 2022
5.00

Home Sale in Toronto, ON | Jul 2022

We had a great experience with Sarah. Professional, timely, and knowledgeable. She was very much in tune with the market which we needed, and her process was transparent and very buttoned down. Highly recommend. - Dave Nourse

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
NO
Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Toronto, ON
Jul 2022
May 2022
5.00

Home in Mt Pleasant East, Toronto, ON | Jun 2022

Sarah Underhill was a pleasure to work with! She has such extensive knowledge of Davisville Village, the area we were looking in. She has fantastic business acumen and great marketing savy. We feel lucky to have chosen Sarah as our agent and would highly recommend her. - Elizabeth Bossick

5.00
5.00
5.00
-
-
5.00
5.00
YES
Buying and Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Mt Pleasant East, Toronto, ON
Jun 2022
May 2022
5.00

Home in Toronto, ON | Nov 2021

Sarah is a true gem - her and Caitin are an amazing team. She is honest and patient - count yourself lucky if she takes you on as a client. - Troy Weston

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
NO
Buying and Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Toronto, ON
Nov 2021
May 2022

Find other Toronto agents.

All profiles and profile information on Rate-My-Agent.com has been provided by users of the site. Rate-My-Agent.com makes no representation as to accuracy of profile information. Specifically, Rate-My-Agent.com and it's owners disclaim any liability relating to the comments, reviews, and ratings posted by users of the website. Rate-My-Agent.com is not attempting to personate any person who's name and/or other identifying information may have been posted on the website.