15 York-Haig, St Catharines Real Estate Agents Ranked by Reviews from 20 Clients | 2026

Only ratings and reviews from buyers and sellers in the York-Haig neighbourhood were used to create this list of York-Haig agents. The rankings are based on triple verified reviews with an emphasis on the newest ratings. For more options, compare ratings and reviews of all St Catharines agents.

#13

Real Estate Agent
St Catharines, ON
4.97
1 client in St Catharines
10 clients in all
Kayla is absolutely amazing to deal with. Her market knowledge, responsivenes...

#14

Plus
Real Estate Agent
St Catharines, ON
4.95
2 clients in St Catharines
47 clients in all
Can't say enough good things about working with Samantha when my wife and I b...

#15

Real Estate Agent
St Catharines, ON
3.00
1 client in St Catharines
2 clients in all
Very unprofessional and rude. I would never recommend hiring Mr. Hewson or hi...

York-Haig, St Catharines, ON Agent Rating Stats

Number of Agents 15
Clients Who Reviewed 20
Clients Who Gave 5 Stars 90.00%
Clients Who Gave 3 Stars or Lower 1
The three "Clients Who" rows count each client once every 12 months, from the date they wrote the review.
Success Rate 85.00%
Average Overall Rating
4.76
Average Knowledgeability Rating
4.80
Average Professionalism Rating
4.80
Average Responsiveness Rating
4.75
Average Usefulness of Website
4.41
Average Value of Service
4.79
Average Marketing Reach & Lead Generation
4.68
Average Home Prep & Staging Advice
4.70

Last Updated: November 20, 2026