Shelley Torrie

Real Estate Agent

33% Response Rate

Badges

This agent has no current badges.

Learn more about badges.

Key Stats

3 reviews in 1 cities.

1st in Keewatin, ON - 3 Reviews

Rating Summary

Overall Rating
2.94
Knowledgeability Rating
3.00
Professionalism Rating
2.33
Responsiveness Rating
3.33
Usefulness of Website
3.33
Value of Service
3.00
Reach & Lead Generation
3.33
Home Prep & Staging Advice
3.00
Success Ratio 33 %
Recommend Ratio 33 %
Response Rate 33 %

Contact

Team Solo
Company
Website Check
Phone Check
Cell Check
Address P.O. Box 357, 721 Beach Road Keewatin, Ontario P0X 1C0


5.00

Home in Keewatin | Jun 2025

I have had the absolute pleasure of working with Shelley Torrie Home and Cottage Real Estate and Shelley Torrie herself for over 15 years, and I can confidently say she is one of the very best in the business. During this time, Shelley has guided me through multiple successful real estate transactions, including the sale of my Lakeside home in Kenora, a downtown property, and most recently, assisted with the purchase of two Keewatin properties/homes in 2025. What sets Shelley apart is her unmatched knowledge, meticulous preparation, and dedication to her clients. She is always prompt, professional, and extremely well-prepared—whether it’s providing market insights, staging advice, or ensuring every detail is handled seamlessly. Her follow-through is second to none; once Shelley commits to something, she sees it through to completion with confidence and care. Shelley’s years of experience show in the way she navigates every step of the buying and selling process. She combines local expertise with an ability to truly understand her clients’ goals, making each transaction smooth and stress-free. She is approachable, responsive, and always puts her clients’ best interests first. It’s no surprise that Shelley is a leading agent and broker in the region—her results speak for themselves. I wholeheartedly give her a perfect 5 out of 5 and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Kenora and Lake of the Woods area. With Shelley, you’re not just hiring a realtor—you’re gaining a trusted partner and advocate. Thanks Shelley! - Lyle Kirchner

5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
YES
Buying and Selling
Successful
YES
House / Single-Family
Keewatin
Jun 2025
September 2025
2.33

Retail Property Purchase in Keewatin | Aug 2025

We asked Shelley to help us find a cottage in NW Ontario as she lives in the area and has been an agent there for many years. We hoped because of the above that we would have a leg up in a very tight market. We were very disappointed in her right from the start. She claimed to know the first cottage she showed us was built by a builder with a good reputation in the area. I have a pretty good eye for building construction and material. The cottage was built with whatever the builder could get his hand on (done on the cheap). We should have dropped here right there. I won't bore you with the in betweens but she really F'd up the last place we dealt with her on. She proved to be arrogent, unwilling to try to bring buyer and seller together after we had expressed mild interest with an offer # we felt fair to negotiate from after a 2nd visit (we wrote a letter to the seller stating so). She scoffed at that and responded, with much hubris that the owner may consider an offer much higher than our starting #. She then, without any effort what so ever let another buyer with another agent swoop in and buy the place (without counteroffers) for less than we were willing to pay for it without even offering a chance to put in a competing offer (and she had the listing so she would have collected both commissions with some effort)! She is totally entitiled, spoiled, incompetent. Definitly would not recommend her. Stay away! - Ray Berendse

Reply:    Having known and worked with/for Shelley Torrie for 25 years, I can say without hesitation that Shelley is the epitome of 'go the extra mile'. Always extremely generous with her time and attention, always respecting and honouring ALL Sellers and Buyers. Her impeccable detailed notes and reports will indicate the integrity with which she applies to all Real Estate dealings. It would seem when one does not get 'what they want in the manner they want' it's much easier to blame someone else. 25 years of Top Rated Agent speaks for itself. Shelley's service to ALL her clients is above and beyond, and 'hubris' is the LAST thing Shelley Torrie is.

4.00
1.00
1.00
4.00
1.00
3.00
-
NO
Buying
Not Successful
NO
Retail
Keewatin
Aug 2025
August 2025
1.50

Property Purchase in Keewatin, ON |

Very poor relationship early into the contract. Totally un-professional know-it-all woman. Every detail turned into an ordeal. We were sorry we ever came in contact with her. - Terrence

1.00
3.00
1.00
1.00
-
2.00
1.00
NO
Buying
Not Successful
NO
Residential
Keewatin, ON
June 2017

Find other Keewatin agents.

All profiles and profile information on Rate-My-Agent.com has been provided by users of the site. Rate-My-Agent.com makes no representation as to accuracy of profile information. Specifically, Rate-My-Agent.com and it's owners disclaim any liability relating to the comments, reviews, and ratings posted by users of the website. Rate-My-Agent.com is not attempting to personate any person who's name and/or other identifying information may have been posted on the website.