Pro Agents
Pro agents have made a commitment to a higher standard of service.
- Ask every client to rate their service.
- Answer every text, call, and email promptly.
They've also proven they have the expertise from a wide variety of successful clients.
Plus Agents
Plus agents have paid for extra features on their account. Buying any kind of subscription does not impact the rankings in any way. Agents must prove their success at the Plus level before they get the opportunity to qualify for Pro.
Key Stats
Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 1 times
22 reviews in 8 cities and 10 neighbourhoods.
18th in Hamilton, ON - 15 Reviews
79th in Burlington, ON - 1 Reviews
17th in Welland, ON - 1 Reviews
23rd in Paris, ON - 1 Reviews
7th in Norfolk County, ON - 1 Reviews
36th in St Catharines, ON - 1 Reviews
14th in Grimsby, ON - 1 Reviews
36th in Niagara Falls, ON - 1 Reviews
Rating Summary
| Overall Rating |
|
| Knowledgeability Rating |
|
| Professionalism Rating |
|
| Responsiveness Rating |
|
| Usefulness of Website |
|
| Value of Service |
|
| Reach & Lead Generation |
|
| Home Prep & Staging Advice |
|
| Success Ratio | 100 % |
| Recommend Ratio | 100 % |
| Response Rate | 100 % |
In Mary's Own Words:
Contact
Home Purchase in Alton North, Burlington | Jun 2026
My wife and I worked with Sarka (Sarah) on Mary’s team for our new purchase. Sarah is extremely knowledge and was very patient with us as she took us to view over 70(!!!) homes. She always gave us expert insight and had a keen eye for details when we viewed each property. We also appreciated Sarah’s negotiation skills and her willingness to fight for us at every possible turn. We highly recommend Sarah and will be referring friends and family to her. - Michael
Townhome Sale in Ancaster, Hamilton | Jun 2026
Mary and her team did a great job selling our home. My wife and I were impressed by the professionalism and level of support from not only Mary, but also everyone on her team supporting her. Paul her staging director and photographer did an amazing job and we were so happy with how our photos turned out for the listing. Mary helped us navigate a tricky market and sell for our target price in a very short time period. We were very worried as we saw lots of similar listings stay on the market for months, but we sold firm within one month. It was a pleasure to deal with Mary and her team, and I would strongly recommend her to anyone. - Michael
Home Sale in Ancaster, Hamilton | Jun 2026
Mary’s Team is well organized, coordinated, and professional. They were very helpful throughout the process and very responsive to my inquiries. The staging of the house for viewings was well done. - Adrian
Home Sale in Ancaster, Hamilton | Sep 2019
Excellent service and communication Mary let us know everything that was important to selling our home. She gave updates every week and promptly gave us the information about showings We would definitely use Mary in the future - Karen Frankiewicz
Home Sale in Niagara Falls | Apr 2026
Mary has been my go to trusted realtor for 2 houses over the last 7 years. Not only is she professional during the process, she went beyond to provide some extra services for me. I am impressed with her staff as Tanya ( admin) was always efficient and the staging crew did a great job.. - Debbie DiMartino
Home Purchase in Berrisfield, Hamilton | Aug 2025
Thank you to Mary and the Mary Hamilton Team for helping us buy our first home! Her experience and professionalism made the process very smooth! We would highly recommend the Mary Hamilton Team! - Joshua Pipe
Townhome Sale in Grimsby | Aug 2016
It has been a great experience working with Mary. From the first meeting to staging everything was very smooth. To this day I value the reports on her Web site, providing current market conditions. - Ernie Kovács
Home Sale in Bruleville, Hamilton | Sep 2021
Knowing the best possible sale usually happens the first time a house is listed, we wanted to do it right and have the best agent. Several agents from the top real estate firms in our market were interviewed. All were good but Mary Hamilton had the edge. She outlined the plan, timeline and staging very clearly. We decided to sign with Mary. The listing and photos were great. The staging with furnishings provided by Mary really made the empty house feel like a home. A well attended open house with many offers. The house sold the very first weekend. Thank You! - Steven Schneefuss
Home Purchase in Berrisfield, Hamilton | Aug 2025
We had a great experience with Mary and the Mary Hamilton Team who helped us buy our first house! We are grateful for her knowledge and expertise and would highly recommend her! - Melanie Pipe
Home Sale in Lakeshore, St Catharines | Oct 2020
Mary and her team are extremely professional and made staging, showing, feedback and communication all very easy. The selling process and negotiation were well handled. I would definitely recommend Mary and her associates. - Peggy Sozansky
Townhome Purchase in Simcoe, Norfolk County | Oct 2025
Highly recommend using Sarka and Mary as your realtor when purchasing or selling your home, they are highly on top of getting things done and working in your best interests. We felt comfortable from the start when working with them on the purchase of our home, she made the process go smoothly and efficiently, she truly is the best. - Mark
Home Sale in Westcliffe East, Hamilton | Feb 2023
Working with Mary Hamilton to sell my mother-in-law’s home was an exceptional experience. From the very beginning, she demonstrated professionalism, expertise, and an incredible work ethic. Thanks to her strategy and marketing, the house was listed and sold at list price within just one week — far beyond what we expected. Mary was always extremely responsive to our questions and kept us informed every step of the way. Her communication was prompt, clear, and reassuring, which made the entire process feel smooth and stress-free. She also staged the home beautifully, highlighting its best features and creating a warm, inviting presentation that truly stood out. In addition, her strong social media presence gave the listing excellent exposure and clearly helped generate immediate interest. We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor. Mary is knowledgeable, dedicated, and genuinely committed to getting the best results for her clients. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. - Maria Rozakis Adcock
Townhome Purchase in Scenic Ridge, Paris | Aug 2025
Sarah and Mary Hamilton team are absolutely fantastic. They are professional and kind and really took time to understand our needs and wants. Their guidance helped us find our perfect home. The process was seamless and easy. We are very happy with the service they provided. - Alexandra Korisanszky
Other reviews for Townhome Purchase in Scenic Ridge, Paris | Aug 2025
"We had a fantastic experience with Mary Hamilton team! She and her team are the perfect blend of professional and kind, making what can be a stressful process feel incredibly smooth. Mary truly exceeded our expectations in every way, going above and beyond to ensure we were taken care of. We can’t recommend her highly enough!" - Peter Korisanszky
Condo in Central Hamilton, Hamilton | Dec 2025
Mary and her team are all incredibly knowledgeable, responsive and always great to work with. Mary has helped me with multiple purchases/sales and I have never been let down by her level of care and service. - Brianne Roy
Home Sale in Hamilton Mountain, Hamilton | Jan 2026
Mary and her team are amazing. From the listing to the sale, everyone was professional and very efficient. Even if I called or texted or emailed them with my concerns and questions, Mary and her team responded promptly and I never felt that my concerns did not matter. Mary and her team were in constant contact with me to ensure I knew what was transpiring and that I was happy. My house was sold during a tumultuous economy, however, I received an amount that I was more than grateful for. I would highly recommend Mary Hamilton. - Kim Howard
Home Sale in Ancaster, Hamilton | Aug 2025
Mary and her team were superb. From the start, Mary demonstrated her attention to detail and knowledge of the market. She always keeps a cool head and was very supportive through the selling process. - Gareth Ellis
Home Sale in Ancaster, Hamilton | Jun 2025
We had the absolute pleasure of working with Mary Hamilton to sell our mom’s home, and we couldn’t be more grateful for her guidance throughout the entire process. From start to finish, Mary was the perfect blend of professional, courteous, and friendly. She treated our family with genuine care, always taking the time to explain each step clearly and thoughtfully. Mary’s expertise and calm approach made what could have been an overwhelming experience feel smooth and manageable. She was incredibly responsive, proactive, and consistently went above and beyond to ensure the best possible outcome for us. Thanks to Mary’s dedication and exceptional service, our mom’s home sold quickly and with minimal stress. We highly recommend Mary Hamilton to anyone looking for a real estate agent who truly puts her clients first. She is an absolute standout in her field. - Ralph Puzzo
Home Sale in Ancaster, Hamilton | Aug 2020
Mary gets the job done!!! It's that simple!!! Hire Mary if you want a no nonsense approach to selling your home. She is very knowledgeable, definitely knows what it takes to move something in the Ancaster area, and she personally dealt with our sale from start to finish. She didn't just grab our listing and then pass it on to one of her associates! During a difficult time for showing and selling homes, late 2019 and early 2020, Mary delivered on what other agents only talked about when it came to representing us and the the sale of our home. Prior to her taking over the marketing and eventual sale of our home from what was for us a disastrous attempt by another agent, that agent and many others, associated and not, made all kinds of assertions about how their multi $$$$ marketing plans were superior. Perhaps COVID scared many of them off however It is our opinion that laying out the "sizzle" part of their plan was more important that delivering a "nice juicy steak"! While others made only an initial contact "sizzle" pitch and were never heard from again, Mary was persistent and as a result of her numerous follow-up's with us prior to entering into an agreement with her, she showed us in detail how she would get the job done. From her own marketing plan to her incredible staging of the home, it sold for what we wanted, setting a new high price for that size home in that area, and all within a very short time frame after she took over. She quickly brought to the table, qualified buyers and not dreamers or tire kickers, she worked around the logistic difficulties brought on by COVID and did so by working around and respecting our demands for enhanced/stringent COVID viewing protocols. If you want more steak and not the sizzle promised by others, hire Mary! - Joe Aceti
Home Sale in Ancaster, Hamilton | Dec 2024
Great agent and wonderful to deal with. We were really pleased with all interactions. Our home was beautifully staged, but the market was not our friend at the time, which made our sale difficult to achieve. - Deb Alexander
Condo Sale in Ancaster, Hamilton | Sep 2025
Was very satisfied with Mary's professionalism and knowledge. Her Assistant Tanya was also very helpful. Mary offered 2 open house which was very much appreciated. I would definitely recommend Mary. - Louise Lachance
Property Sale in Ancaster, Hamilton, ON |
It was a pleasure working with Mary and her team. They are all very professional and responsive. Mary provides excellent service in all aspects of selling, including staging and helping me to prepare the property for sale, with referrals to helpful trades, and even taking on some of the expense of some of the minor upgrades to help the property show well, to get top dollar! - Frimmy Burnstein
In an industry that’s littered with below average agents, Mary and her team are an absolute standout! We received extreme professionalism from day 1 all the way through to closing day. The team including Tanya genuinely went above and beyond to ensure everything was taken care of and that the entire process was smooth! Mary has a deep understanding of the marketplace and she tells it to you like it is; her job is to get you the best possible deal in that market and she did that for us! 100% would recommend this team! - Zeeshan Ahmed