Caitlin McKenna
Personal Real Estate Corporation
96% Response Rate
Pro Agents
Pro agents have made a commitment to a higher standard of service.
- Ask every client to rate their service.
- Answer every text, call, and email promptly.
They've also proven they have the expertise from a wide variety of successful clients.
Plus Agents
Plus agents have paid for extra features on their account. Buying any kind of subscription does not impact the rankings in any way. Agents must prove their success at the Plus level before they get the opportunity to qualify for Pro.
Key Stats
Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 14 times
77 reviews in 7 cities and 14 neighbourhoods.
3rd in Duncan, BC - 56 Reviews
2nd in Ladysmith, BC - 6 Reviews
1st in Lake Cowichan, BC - 6 Reviews
2nd in Cobble Hill, BC - 3 Reviews
3rd in Shawnigan Lake, BC - 3 Reviews
41st in Langford, BC - 2 Reviews
3rd in Youbou, BC - 1 Reviews
Track Record
#4 in Duncan, BC - 2025
#5 in Duncan, BC - 2024
#2 in Duncan, BC - 2023
#2 in Duncan, BC - 2022
#1 in Duncan, BC - 2021
#2 in Duncan, BC - 2020
#1 in Duncan, BC - 2019
6 Years on Rate-My-Agent.com
Rating Summary
| Overall Rating |
|
| Knowledgeability Rating |
|
| Professionalism Rating |
|
| Responsiveness Rating |
|
| Usefulness of Website |
|
| Value of Service |
|
| Reach & Lead Generation |
|
| Home Prep & Staging Advice |
|
| Success Ratio | 100 % |
| Recommend Ratio | 100 % |
| Response Rate | 96 % |
Contact
Home in Duncan | Oct 2025
Caitlin is Highly Professional. She is Prompt. She is Exacting in her paperwork. She is Friendly to all persons involved in the process. She is thoughtfully Accomodating. She is truly an Original Thinker. - Robyn Arbuckle
Condo Purchase in Bear Mountain, Langford | May 2025
My experience with Caitlin was nothing short of amazing. From the very beginning, she made the entire process of finding a place feel effortless and completely stress-free. She always kept me in the loop, was quick to communicate, and made sure I never felt left in the dark. No matter how many questions I had (and I had a lot), she always found the answer. What stood out the most was how much she truly had my back throughout the whole journey. I always felt like she was looking out for my best interests, whether it was giving honest advice and helping me weigh my options. I couldn’t recommend Caitlin enough! - Adam
Townhome Purchase in Ladysmith | Sep 2025
Caitlin was honest, very knowledgeable and went above and beyond to make sure I was informed and understanding of the entire process. Caitlin presents professionally and is indeed professional in the information she provided. I would highly recommend her to anyone needing to purchase a property. - Marlene Houghton
Home Sale in Duncan | Jul 2025
Caitlin came highly recommended by friends who had sold their house through her. Our experience working with Caitlin was as they had described their own. Caitlin was very professional, knowledgeable, responsive, friendly, direct, honest and a pleasure to work with. I would not hesitate to work with her again and also highly recommend her. - Angela Neumann
Home in Cobble Hill | Jul 2025
Complete package professional and wonderful human being. Caitlin was at arms reach throughout the entire process, available through call, text or a quick visit to help facilitate every aspect of our home sale and purchase. We came with questions, Caitlin found answers. We came with problems, Caitlin found solutions. Ultimately what could have been an extremely stressful period of change, was a seamless transition from one home to another. We can’t thank Caitlin enough for all her efforts and will certainly recommend her moving forward. - Brandon Feltis
Home Purchase in Duncan | Jun 2025
I highly recommend Caitlin. She’s professional, knowledgeable, and really knows the business. She listens to what you are really looking for and helps find options. She’s also great at "going to bat" when it comes to the tough negotiations! - Ian Willey
Home Sale in Shawnigan Lake | Jun 2025
This is the second time we have used Caitlin, previously when buying a house and this time for selling. She is friendly, knowledgeable and responsive and was a great asset in getting our house sold in a matter of days! Thanks so much for all your help Caitlin, it has been a pleasure working with you! - Steven Kimler
Townhome Purchase in Z3 Ladysmith, Ladysmith | Apr 2025
Caitlin has been an absolute dream as a buyers' agent. She is knowledgeable about the area and about real estate issues, prompt in responding to messages and calls and did her best to help us find a home we love. We really appreciate how clearly she explained things to us and also the depth of her knowledge. - Marcia J.
Home Sale in Ladysmith | Jun 2024
Working with Caitlin was a fantastic experience. She is very professional, knowledgeable and has outstanding communication skills. Caitlin goes above and beyond at every corner. She promptly answered calls and emails keeping me informed about every detail. I would highly recommend Caitlin McKenna. - Carol
Home Purchase in Z3 Ladysmith, Ladysmith | Jan 2025
As first time home buyers, we appreciated Caitlin’s thoughtful guidance while we navigated a steep learning curve. She is a professional, knowledgeable, resourceful, approachable, and diligent realtor. We would absolutely recommend her services. - Jillian Wheatley
Other reviews for Home Purchase in Z3 Ladysmith, Ladysmith | Jan 2025
Wonderful experience working with Caitlin, she was friendly and knowledgeable and quick to respond to our questions. As first time home buyers she made us feel very safe in her hands. We couldn’t have done it without her. Highly recommended! - Christopher Ross
Townhome Sale in Duncan | Nov 2024
Caitlin is exceptional, and i would without hesitation work with her again. Highly recommend her for her knowledge, passion and work ethic. She was aa pleasure to work with right from the beginning. - james tobler
Farm Sale in Cowichan Valley, Lake Cowichan | Jul 2024
Highly recommend Caitlin, she is so very good at what she does. Attention to details, professional, hard working, knowledgeable, easy to understand and work with. Couldn’t have done it with out Caitlin. 20 out of 10 she is fantastic!!!!! - Sophie
Home Sale in Lake Cowichan | Jun 2024
It was such a pleasure working with Caitlin on the sale of our property. Our sale was quite complex as our property was co owned by two families and had shared amenities with the neighbouring property. We also had very close relations with the neighbours on both sides of our property and wanted to find the right people that would fit into the community we had built. Caitlin took all this in stride and created a detailed plan on how we could sell for the price we wanted and to the right people. Caitlin was professional, realistic, very detailed, and worked with four peoples schedules throughout the whole process. On top of all that Caitlin was very lovely person to work with. She put everything in the simplest terms possible so we could understand and made sure we knew and understand all the processes involved in the sale. We ended up selling our property in under a week with little to no complications for our desired price. She did all of this while she was several months pregnant as well. Couldn’t ask for a better realtor. I would highly recommend Caitlin to anyone selling or buying a property. Thanks Caitlin! - Taylor Easton
Home Sale in Lake Cowichan | Jul 2024
Caitlin is an amazing realtor. She was great to work with and really showed up for us in so many ways, and went above and beyond her call of duty. We were first time sellers, so it was all new to us, and she held our hand through it all. She also was able to work with us on a vrey unique property with very unique needs of finding a specific kind of buyer. So this was a much more challenging property and sell than most, and yet she stepped up to it with no hesitation, thought outside the box, and met all of our needs, helping us find the perfect buyers. We are so extremely grateful for Caitlin and highly recommend her as a realtor! - Jasper Sircus
Home Purchase in Lake Cowichan | Jul 2024
I worked on this deal with Caitlin where I was representing the buyers on her listing. This deal was far from straight forward and was actually quite complex. After a few subject extensions and many phone calls and emails, we were able to remove subjects and go firm on the sale. Caitlin was very knowledgable and fantastic to work with. She kept her cool throughout the entire process and was understanding of the complexity of the deal. She relayed info between her clients and mine in a calm, cool, collected manner and worked closely with me to get this deal across the finish line. I would recommend Caitlin to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate in Lake Cowichan and surrounding areas. - Conor Kinsella
Home Purchase in Duncan | Jun 2024
As a first-time home buyer, there’s no one I’d rather have in my corner than Caitlin. She is straightforward, honest, thorough, detail-oriented, and reliable. Caitlin truly understands her client’s needs and priorities and makes no pressure recommendations tailored to you. She is an absolute pleasure to work with and I feel she did a phenomenal job helping us purchase our home. We would 100% work with her again, and would recommend her to others. - Ivy
Home Purchase in Duncan | May 2024
Caitlin was our second realtor in the process of buying our home, and the difference was night and day. She was knowledgeable and honest with us, and brought a perspective to the table that we were missing. This is not our first house, but we are not seasoned buyers, and having her suggestions and observations helped us to avoid expensive mistakes and find a home we are thrilled with. Caitlin worked extremely quickly to get our offer put together, and continued to be responsive and helpful after the signed offer was accepted. She walked us through the process and provided support above and beyond what we expected from a realtor. - Naomi
Home Purchase in Duncan | May 2024
Caitlin is a gem and was a pleasure to work with. Her patience with us was such a blessing to our family.Her knowledge and professionalism helped us secure our dream home. Thanks for everything Caitlin! - Alicia Diestler
Home in Cobble Hill | Feb 2024
We have been in touch/working with Caitlin since 2020 when we found her on Instagram about a property she had listed. We kept in contact over the years and had viewed quite a few places but never the right one. She was always very fast to respond and willing to show and provide additional information about any that we were interested in. We finally found a place at the end of 2023, at a time we honestly weren’t really looking. With her expertise and advice she made the process of putting in an offer, accepting an offer as well as selling our current property (very fast) so smooth and seamless without feeling stressed. Her knowledge, kindness and communication skills are exemplary. We fully trust and value the input and advice given and were able to make confident decisions throughout the whole process. We can’t recommend her enough and have already sent a few family members her way! Caitlin has always been - Kylie Jollymore
Home Sale in Duncan | Aug 2023
Late last summer we had the pleasure of working with Caitlin as our realtor, and we cannot recommend her highly enough. With her extensive knowledge of the local real estate market, Caitlin expertly guided us through every step of the selling process. Her professionalism and attention to detail ensured that we were well-informed and confident in our decisions. Caitlin’s dedication to understanding our needs and preferences truly stood out, as she went above and beyond to find the perfect buyer for us as we moved across the province. If you're looking for a realtor who combines competence with genuine care for her clients' satisfaction, Caitlin is the ideal choice. - Dawn Rorick
Home Sale in Duncan | Nov 2023
We were extremely lucky to have found Caitlin. During these current difficult times where the market is very slow and the interest rates have been going up 10+ over the last 18 months, we could not have had a better person to guide us in the sale of our house. Caitlin is a total professional in every respect. She is super organized, trustworthy, pro-active and totally focused in achieving her customer's goals. She went over and above to make sure our house was ready for showing every single time; no matter what day of the week. Her persistence and attention to details is amazing. Thank you so much for guiding us through the long process. - Constanze Draper
Home Purchase in Duncan | Oct 2023
Caitlin was very professional! Her promptness, knowledge of the market, strategic mindset, kindness, good energy made a potentially chaotic purchase process simple. I’ve already recommended her to a family member. When I am looking to buy or sell again I will not hesitate to call Caitlin. - Adam Couture
Townhome Purchase in Duncan | Sep 2023
Caitlin worked incredibly hard for us over a long period of time as we looked to purchase our first home. We would not have closed on the place we did buy without her diligence, knowledge, and work ethic under a tight deadline. I have no hesitation recommending her. :) - Nathan Bender
Other reviews for Townhome Purchase in Duncan | Sep 2023
Caitlin helped my husband and I purchase our first home and supported us in navigating a tricky market. She stayed with us despite a very lengthy search, and ultimately, she helped us make an excellent purchase. In fact, she even suggested the place we ended up purchasing— a townhouse that eventually entered our price range. Caitlin is knowledgeable and will find the answers you need. She is relentlessly positive, even when outlooks are unfavourable. She is trustworthy, dependable, insightful, and professional, and I’ve already recommended her services to family. - Kate Dewhurst
Home Purchase in Duncan | Jul 2023
Caitlin was super efficient, knowledgeable, pleasant and offered valuable advice. We would have no problem recommending her for all your real estate needs! She even provided us with slippers as we walked through peoples homes. Caitlin and Shelley make an awesome team! - Bernie Harris
Home Purchase in Duncan | Jul 2023
Caitlin worked incredibly hard and provided very valuable advice during a difficult negotiation with a difficult seller. Could not have got to the finish line without her diligence. Amazing realtor. - David Harris
Home Sale in East Duncan, Duncan | Aug 2023
We interviewed three agents that served the Duncan area. Caitlin impressed us the most right away. This is a rave review and is well deserved. She answers calls, texts and emails right away, with clarity. She helped to organized our time in preparing the house for sale. She and her husband help us move some things from my parents home. Her advice was always so appreciated. She is a very warm person, she is very smart and also a good listener of our concerns; and she gets to her point very quickly. This saves us all a lot of time as we discuss, evaluate and negotiate offers. Our home was put on the market during rising interest rates and it looked like a tough market. Caitlin help us get a great price very close to what we were asking. We highly recommend her for her skill set, experience, and people skills. - Henry Bittner
Home Purchase in Duncan | May 2023
I can't recommend a better agent up in the Cowichan Valley than Caitlin McKenna. Caitlin has been taking care of all of my clients up that way for the last few years, and they have nothing but amazing things to say about her experience, communication, professionalism, and delivery. She truly cares about her job and her clients, and it shows. She continually demonstrates her high level of skill, and I wouldn't hesitate in recommending her. - Danielle Moreau
Townhome Purchase in Victoria, Langford | Jun 2023
Caitlan was very responsive to our needs. She has a great knowledge of the area and directed us to areas and listings that were appropriate to our needs. Happily recommend her to anyone coming to Victoria - Les Homme
Home Purchase in Z3 Lake Cowichan, Lake Cowichan | Jun 2023
Caitlin is truly one of a kind. Efficient, patient, and honest. The perfect qualities required to make any tricky situation seamless. Caitlin took a huge weight off my shoulders by managing any bump along the way with a positive attitude and always took the time to make sure I felt satisfied every step along the way. If it was possible to rate my experience a 6 out of 5 I would. - Mckayla Vancoughnett
Home Purchase in West Duncan, Duncan | May 2023
Caitlin was so great to work with! Her knowledge and experience in the Cowichan Valley really shone through. Would 100% recommend! We can't wait to work with you on the next one! Thanks Caitlin! - Nick
Home Sale in Duncan East, Duncan | Apr 2023
Caitlin was an absolute dream to work with. She exceeded expectations throughout the entire selling process. She was an ally, friend, and advisor and really helped us navigate the entire exercise. Caitlin was knowledgeable, helpful and made things incredibly easy. We cannot imagine a better experience and will definitely recommend her to others who are looking to buy/sell. - Yvette Marquis
Home Sale in Duncan | May 2023
I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Caitlin, she was supportive, knowledgeable, professional and went above and beyond helping me sell my house. During our time together Caitlin helped in any way she could. - Ms Suzanne M Didier
Home in Cowichan Valley, Youbou | Feb 2019
Caitlin helped me so much during the process of putting an offer in on a home with a contingency of selling my condo. She knew it was a stressful situation for me and helped me through the process. With each showing of my condo she provided valuable feedback so i could understand why i may or may not get an offer. Caitlin made herself available for any questions i had during the process and was very responsive. Even 4 years later, if i have real estate questions or need some information that i think she might know (like who to contact for a property survey or whatever it may be) she always takes the time to get back to me. This says a lot about someone's work ethic and how she truly just loves what she does and cares about her clients. I even get a Christmas card from her every year! I have worked with many realtors before and not one has ever been as diligent, hard working, and caring as Caitlin! - Monica A.
Home Sale in Shawnigan Lake | Apr 2023
Wow! Caitlin's approach to real estate is raising the bar for realtors! Caitlin brought us multiple offers in a buyer's market within a week of listing after a highly recommended realtor failed to sell our property. Not only was the entire experience with Caitlin amazing, but we made significantly more money on our sale. It's hard to accurately capture all the work Caitlin did for us because it was so extensive. We interviewed multiple realtors after having a previously failed and stressful experience. Caitlin offered a level of service, attention and professionalism that was not being offered by any other realtor we spoke with. In addition to the typical realtor services, Caitlin provided sales strategy and support before, during and after listing, hands on help with prepping our 2.5 acre property (she even helped us move furniture!!), pulled together a team of amazing professionals (stager, cleaner, photographer) to support us and overall handled the entire process with such ease that I could confidently hand the lead over to her. I will never use another realtor other than Caitlin! - Lori Wagar
Townhome Purchase in Duncan | Nov 2022
We really enjoyed working with Caitlin to find our first home that had everything that we were looking for. She was always available to talk when we needed advice, and was by our side every step of the way which made our purchase more enjoyable and less stressful knowing that she was there to help us with anything we needed. We would recommend her services to anyone who is in need of a great real estate agent. We couldn't have asked for a better real estate agent than her. She made it such an enjoyable experience for us. Thanks again Caitlin. - Stephen smith
Home Sale in West Duncan, Duncan | Dec 2022
Our experience of selling our home with Caitlin’s support has been easy, comfortable, and well taken care of. These are not words we usually associate with selling a home and moving but Caitlin’s professional, dedicated approach and her attention to detail gave us the confidence in her ability to manage the transaction well and deal with any challenges that might come up. Her knowledge of the market is very strong, and assessment of our home was bang on. Caitlin possesses the sensitivity and compassion necessary to support people during something that can be very stressful. She was always responsive to our needs and concerns, even when it was likely not convenient for her. We were especially impressed with her eye for what was special and unique about our home. She focused on bringing out the best in our home instead of trying to make it look like something it wasn’t. Caitlin has been a joy to work with and we would recommend her, unreservedly, to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Cowichan Valley. - Brad Crewson
Home Purchase in Z3 Lake Cowichan, Lake Cowichan | Jul 2022
I hardly know where to start with the amazing service we received from Caitlin during our search for the best home. From the get go, I really felt she took the time to get to know us personally to better understand our needs in looking for the perfect property. That personal touch really helped build trust immediately and I knew she was the best realtor for us and our search. She advocated for us in a multiple offer situation and ultimately helped us attain our dream home!!! I would 1000% recommend Caitlin for all of your real estate needs and you will not be disappointed!! Her passion, dedication and commitment to her clients puts her miles above the rest. Thank you SO much Caitlin for everything you did for us. It was a real pleasure working with you and we absolutely love being new residents of the Cowichan Valley :) - Karyn Rainer
Home Sale in Cowichan Bay, Duncan | Oct 2022
Caitlin is incredible! I appreciate her reliability, professionalism, patience, and knowledge of the real estate market so much. I can't imagine working with anyone else, she has been such a wonderful realtor for our family! - Rachel Winter
Home Purchase in Shawnigan Lake, Duncan | Sep 2022
Home Sale in Z3 Shawnigan, Shawnigan Lake | Jun 2022
From the first time I emailed Caitlin about selling my home she was responsive, energetic, knowledgable and keen to make the most of the opportunity for both of us. Despite the fact that I sold at the peak of the sellers market in 2022 she went above and beyond to make sure my home looked its best and got lots of exposure. From rolling up her sleeves to help me move furniture, to going door to door to make sure all the neighbours knew the property was for sale, she impressed me with her enthusiasm and attitude. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend her to anyone who wants an agent who will work hard to maximize the value of their home. - Kari
Home Purchase in Cobble Hill, Duncan, BC | May 2022
Caitlin is a breath of fresh air in this crazy housing market! She was patient and took her time with us, ensuring we were able to find something we loved and not having to settle just to close a deal. She did not make us feel pressured in anyway and was incredibly professional and relatable. She has a solid understanding of the Cowichan Valley and helped us to make a smart decision for our family. In the end, we had an accepted offer WITH conditions which made us feel so much better when making that big of a purchase. Caitlin was right beside us each step of the way until we found our dream property and we can't thank her enough! I highly recommend Caitlin to anyone looking for a house - she is truly the best!! - Candace
Home Purchase in Duncan, BC | Apr 2022
I’ve delt with a number of agents over the last 35 years and I can honestly say she is, by far, the most professional, well informed agent I have ever dealt with. I’m recommended her to other family members looking to relocate to Cowichan Valley. - Jeff
Home Purchase in Duncan, BC | Apr 2022
We are Seniors moving from the Mainland to the Island and are very happy with all the help and advice that Caitlin gave us to help us be able to secure the absolutely perfect home for us in a very competitive market. She was very quick to look after things and very helpful with our specific needs. - Pat Cruickshank
Home Purchase in Cobble Hill, BC | Apr 2022
Caitlin was a pleasure to deal with and we highly recommend her. We are located on the mainland, purchased a property in the Cowichan Valley and Caitlin was extremely helpful in guiding us to the right purchase in a market we knew little about. She was responsive any time of day and always made us feel that we are her number one priority, She always handled herself in a professional manner. If she didn't have answers to our questions, she used her resources to get answers and always reliable to follow up. It is not all about the transaction for Caitlin. She truly wants to do the best thing for all, applying her compassion and expressing her concerns. Additional to being a great realtor, she also is helping us with planning our move, including referrals to local services. Don't hesitate to use Caitlin's services. You WON'T regret it! - Sandy Dennis
Townhome Purchase in Ladysmith, BC | Feb 2022
As first time home buyers my partner and I feel as though we could not have been in better hands. Caitlin is extremely knowledgeable, she explained the process thoroughly every step of the way happily answering all of my silly questions. Caitlin is thoughtful and considerate throughout the buying process, an excellent advocate with great attention to detail. Thank you for all of your help Caitlin! - Kierra Downey
Home Purchase in Shawnigan Lake, Duncan, BC | Dec 2021
Caitlin is lovely! This is the 3rd house I’ve purchased and Caitlin is (by far) the best relitor I’ve ever had. I highly recommend her. She keeps in great contact, is kind, thorough, and knowledgeable. She really went above and beyond. She was committed to finding us a house that would work for the unique needs of a multigenerational family. We were so lucky to have found her. - Melissa Henderson
Townhome Purchase in Duncan, BC | Sep 2021
Caitlin is the best realtor we have ever known. She really looked after us. She always came prepared and gave us her honest opinions. We felt that she always had our interest at heart. We are so grateful to have met her and would highly recommend her. - patricia hazard
Home Purchase in Duncan, BC | Nov 2022
Was very pleased with my experience with Caitlin, she is extremely knowledgable and willing to share wisdom! Made the very stressful process less stressful. She is very kind and easy to work with and has her clients best interest at heart - Page
Home Purchase in Crofton, Duncan, BC | Nov 2021
Caitlin is a kind, patient, tenacious person. Professional and courteous and really did go above and beyond. She stuck through the thick of it with us and through her expertise we were able to find a compromise we felt confident in! - Rosa Toste
Caitlin is very professional and easy to work with. She was available 7 days a week and most any time of the day. We live many provinces away from BC and were able to make this sale happen. - Klaus Tietz