Pro Agents
Pro agents have made a commitment to a higher standard of service.
- Ask every client to rate their service.
- Answer every text, call, and email promptly.
They've also proven they have the expertise from a wide variety of successful clients.
Plus Agents
Plus agents have paid for extra features on their account. Buying any kind of subscription does not impact the rankings in any way. Agents must prove their success at the Plus level before they get the opportunity to qualify for Pro.
Key Stats
Hired on Rate-My-Agent.com 10 times
155 reviews in 4 cities and 54 neighbourhoods.
9th in Winnipeg, MB - 151 Reviews
7th in Stonewall, MB - 2 Reviews
10th in Oakbank, MB - 1 Reviews
3rd in Spring Hill, FL - 1 Reviews
Track Record
#3 in Winnipeg, MB - 2025
#6 in Winnipeg, MB - 2024
#9 in Winnipeg, MB - 2021
11 Years on Rate-My-Agent.com
Rating Summary
| Overall Rating |
|
| Knowledgeability Rating |
|
| Professionalism Rating |
|
| Responsiveness Rating |
|
| Usefulness of Website |
|
| Value of Service |
|
| Reach & Lead Generation |
|
| Home Prep & Staging Advice |
|
| Success Ratio | 100 % |
| Recommend Ratio | 100 % |
| Response Rate | 82 % |
In Josh's Own Words:
Contact
Condo Sale in Meadows, Winnipeg | Mar 2023
Josh made the entire selling process incredibly easy and accessible. He was very communicative with updates and responsive to any questions. Josh is professional, knowledgeable, in addition to being kind and hilarious! I would absolutely recommend his services to anyone. - Amy
Home Purchase in Winnipeg | Dec 2022
Josh is excellent! He took the time to get to know me and gain an understanding of what I needed. Then he showed me properties that matched my needs and worked well within my budget. When I showed interest in properties that didn’t match my needs, he gently reminded me of previous talks to ensure I didn’t lose sight of what was important to me. Love his integrity!! Love his sense of humour as well :) - Pat Remillard
Home Purchase in Meadows, Winnipeg | Oct 2022
Home Purchase in Wellington Crescent, Winnipeg | Aug 2022
Condo Purchase in Lord Roberts, Winnipeg | Nov 2022
I was looking to move to Winnipeg from Ontario and had a short window to look at properties while in the area. Josh was incredibly helpful narrowing my search and organizing viewings in that window as well as giving me advice and background on the areas I was looking in, which was critical given I was not from the area. - John Matheson
Townhome Sale in La Salle Park, Winnipeg | Dec 2022
When I finally decided to sell my house Josh was extremely helpful and supportive. He explained everything and kept me in the loop and well informed. The house sold quickly (2 weeks, in a slowing down market) with a quick possession date. I will absolutely recommend Josh and his team to anyone who is selling or buying a home. - Nicole Dupéré
Home Purchase in Canterbury Park, Winnipeg | Sep 2022
Josh is a charismatic, knowledgeable and very down to Earth realtor. He always made time for my family and I, gave us honest advice about properties and areas and worked within our timeline to help find us our perfect home. He helped us buy more than a house, he listened to who were were as a family and helped us find a home that fit our lifestyle and goals. Josh realizes that buying a home can be an emotional and stressful time. We never felt pressured, and he was there as a professional and friend when we needed him. I would strongly recommend working with Josh! - Paige Bannister
Townhome Purchase in La Salle Park, Winnipeg | Dec 2022
Was awesome to me, I am a younger person and he didn’t even care he treated me like he treated any other person. Some other realtors would just ignore me, he took to time to listen to me and he helped me out to get everything together very nice person totally recommend him. - Codie
Home Purchase in Inkster-Faraday, Winnipeg | Aug 2022
Home in Transcona, Winnipeg | Nov 2022
Great availability and prompt responses. Very knowledgeable about the properties he shows you. Josh is super easy to talk to and genuinely enthusiastic about helping you find a home. He is honest and upfront about the properties he shows you. - Lisa Walker
Home Sale in Minto, Winnipeg | Nov 2022
Josh was really knowledgeable, professional and caring. I was very nervous about selling and Josh talked to me when I needed it and made me feel like everything would work in which it all did work out perfectly! - Kristel Van De Kerckhove
Home Sale in St Andrews, Winnipeg | Aug 2022
Home Sale in Radisson, Winnipeg | Jun 2022
Condo Purchase in River-Osborne, Winnipeg | Jun 2022
Josh was completely amazing. I have purchased homes all over Canada and this was by far the most memorable experience. The home in question was for my son, and I was not able to see prior to purchase. Josh's expertise, patience and amazing work ethic made this a very smooth transaction - Brodie Lynn Butler
Home in Chalmers, Winnipeg | Jun 2022
Highly recommend Josh and the team at Goodfellow Realty. Everyone was a pleasure to work with and extremely helpful. Josh was fantastic with answering random questions from someone who wasn't familiar with the real estate processes at all. Much appreciated! - Stacey Woligroski
Home Purchase in Norwood East, Winnipeg | Jun 2022
Josh is spectacular. Professional, friendly, responsive, and has a great intuition for finding a house that is a good fit for you. My brother and I were first time buyers, and we found a fantastic house that we are very excited about. We couldn't have done it without you, Josh! Thanks :) - John Anderson
Condo Sale in Fort Richmond, Winnipeg | Apr 2022
Josh is exceptionally capable of managing the purchase and sale of any property. He listens, he respects, he represents, he follows through, he is kind with his opinions, he will make a difficult situation seem easy. He likes to laugh and takes all the time you need to understand information to make big decisions. - CJ
Home Purchase in Riverview, Winnipeg | Oct 2013
Josh was a fantastic Realtor for our first time home buying experience! Josh was happy to show us anything we asked, multiple showings per day, and even put up with our parents coming along for the ride! Josh was excellent at referring us to other services as well, including a mortgage broker and real estate lawyer, without any obligation to use them. We look forward to working with Josh again as we look at upgrading to meet our evolving housing needs! - Daniel Trenchard
Home Sale in Winnipeg, MB | Jun 2022
Josh proved to be an exceptional agent whose knowledge, professionalism and willingness were outstanding. He worked with us every step of the way and gave first class service. I absolutely recommend him to anyone looking for an agent who will do their best for their clients. - John Micklefield
Condo in Broadway-Assiniboine, Winnipeg, MB | Jul 2022
I don't hesitate to recommend Josh to anyone I talk to that is thinking about selling their house. He was very professional and accommodating, always available to answer any questions I had. He was a pleasure to work with. - Steve Jaques
Home in Munroe East, Winnipeg, Manitoba | May 2022
Josh was professional and available. He had great advice and was patient and not pushy. He was genuinely interested in finding us a good home that matched our wants and needs. - Julie
Home in Munroe East, Winnipeg, MB | May 2022
Josh is a knowledgeable and patient agent. No pressure agent who gets answers to all questions quickly and efficiently. He also is honest and would not let us purchase a house that was not good enough. Josh is also respected in the real estate community. - Tracy Edwards
Home Sale in Elmhurst, Winnipeg, MB | Oct 2021
Josh was very professional with a good understanding of the real estate market in Winnipeg. He achieved higher than expected results. He kept us informed of the process and the result throughout the sale - Thomas Yeates
Home Purchase in Winnipeg, MB |
As an insurance agent here in Winnipeg, I have a unique perspective dealing with many realtors here in the province - buying and selling. I can say from experience Josh and his team have been extraordinary to work with and always prioritize their clients interests over their own. Josh's professionalism, genuine kindness and desire to see others succeed can't be matched. The attention to detail and personalized service he provides to each of his clients speaks volumes to his character and you immediately feel like family. You will not be disappointed working with Josh. - Robin Ramsay
Home Purchase in Meadows, Winnipeg, MB | Nov 2009
Home Sale in Meadows, Winnipeg, MB | Oct 2010
Condo Sale in Meadows, Winnipeg, MB | Aug 2020
Home Sale in Eaglemere, Winnipeg, MB | May 2021
Josh was a pleasure to work with. He answered all our questions, was never “pushy” and just helped my husband and I make well-informed decisions through a process that can otherwise be pretty stressful. - Andreina Holliday
Condo Purchase in Winnipeg, MB | Dec 2021
As a first time buyer, I was a bit uncertain, but Josh provided great service. He answered all my questions. Never too much pressure, always helpful, informative and responsive. I’d definitely contact him if I were in the market again. - Kevin Klassen
Home Purchase in Oakbank, Winnipeg, Manitoba | Dec 2021
This was the second time we've bought from Josh! Josh was always keen to see houses, which were many due to the current market which made us feel not rushed in any decision. - Stephen Taylor
Home Sale in Chalmers, Winnipeg, MB | Jul 2021
Amazing person to deal with. We had so many questions, and Josh was able to help us though everything! We couldn’t have, and wouldn’t have been able to get through selling and buying without him - Jen
Home Purchase in Canterbury Park, Winnipeg, MB | Apr 2019
Showed us multiple homes, went out of his way making many trips to the office when we were making offers. Always looking out for our best interest . We ended up finding and were super happy! - Shayne gingras
Home Sale in Transcona, Winnipeg, MB | Jun 2020
Knowledgeable, thorough, professional, friendly! Great sale from start to finish. Great staging recommendations, excellent use of pictures and video of the house on the listing. Organized showings. Great communication with agents. Easy bid revue. Easy close. Overall perfect performance. Well done Josh! - Dan Lafond
Home Sale in Riverview, Winnipeg, MB | Dec 2021
Josh has been my agent for 3 transactions and I intend on working with him forever! He is extremely reliable, knowledgeable, and professional. He answered hundreds of my questions and made every transaction as stress free as possible. - Vanessa Armstrong
Home Sale in Eaglemere, Winnipeg, MB | Jul 2021
Josh Gibson, you’re an absolute pleasure to deal with. Your level of service is extraordinary! Your care and passion for customer service is beyond anything we could have dreamed of. Thank you for your guidance and ongoing support through this overwhelming process. - Keith Holliday
Property in Winnipeg, MB | Apr 2021
Josh was great to work with and a bonus is now funny he is. He was very open about the process and kept us in the loop on different situations throughout the buying process. When there was a problem on the sellers side he offered to give up his commission to ensure the sale went through. Top notch! - Alexandrea Austin-Anderson
Property in Winnipeg, MB | Jul 2021
We really enjoyed working with Josh and the Goodfellow team on both transactions. Josh is easy-going, extremely knowledgeable and was quick to respond to our many questions. For the sale, the photos and video came out awesome. The staging alone, I think, more than paid for the commission. 100% we would use them again! - Brent
Property Sale in Winnipeg, MB | Jul
Super helpful with closing my dads estate. Can not thank him enough. He was very understanding and considerate through a difficult dynamic. I would highly recommend Josh to anyone looking for an honest agent - B
Property in Winnipeg, MB | Jul 2006
Josh was incredibly personable and knowledgeable; anticipated needs; was available and very responsive; and made the whole experience of selling and buying low stress and fun. Thankful to have him as my agent. - Jodie
Property Purchase in Winnipeg, MB | Aug 2013
Josh uses a no-pressure approach and genuinely cares about getting people the home they want. As a first-time home-buyer I was anxious about the process, and his mixture of professionalism and enthusiasm completely transformed my nerves into excitement. - Breanne Macmillan
Property in Winnipeg, MB | May 2016
Josh was amazing to work with! We had a successful and fun time with buying our first house. He asked great questions to help us focus on what we were looking for and really listened to us. With this feedback he was able to give us great options to choose from to meet our needs, including things we hadn’t even thought of. Once we chose our house he was very knowledgeable about the process, including the required financing, legal aspects and negotiating a fair price for us. We had an equally amazing experience selling our first home and buying our dream home 8 years later. The house was staged beautifully and sold within 3 days and for more than we were expecting. Buying and selling a house is such a stressful process, but with Josh the process was actually lots of fun, and he alleviate so much of the stress for us. Would highly recommend :) - Jaime N Macmillan
Property Purchase in Winnipeg, MB | Jul 2021
Josh was amazing could not be happier absolute pleasure to deal with and extremely knowledgeable on the entire process. 110 percent, he went above board on the process front to back. You can be reassured josh is your guy for the job. - Quinn Riddolls
Property in Winnipeg, MB | May 2021
Josh was excellent! Very supportive, went out of his way to show us many houses, kept us encouraged in a difficult market. He represented our interests in both buying and selling in an authentic way with integrity. - Janessa Sequeira
Property Sale in Winnipeg, MB | Sep 2021
We have dealt with Josh several times in the past and his results speak for themselves. I wouldn’t hesitate to refer any of family or friends to Josh Very impressed with the staging and photographing of our condo. We love his manner of doing business. He is very thorough and professional. We love him to death. - Margie and Mark
Property in Winnipeg, MB | Feb 2019
Josh is fantastic we cannot put it into words! He is knowledgeable, honest, and patient. He will fight hard for his clients and is the only person I would ever want to work with if we ever in the market for a new home in the future. I have recommended Josh to every friend & family member we know and will continue to do so! - Victoria
Property in Winnipeg, MB | Jun 2020
Josh Gibson was incredibly knowledgable and helpful with the sale of my old home and the purchase of my new home. He took calls at all hours and was very patient and understanding with my questions and concerns. I received an amount well over my asking price and was thrilled with the amount of people that came through my home. I would definitely recommend him to anyone buying or selling a home. - S Gibson
Property Sale in Winnipeg, MB | Jun 2021
I experienced amazing service when selling my condo this summer - Josh is very knowledgeable and professional, and provides results! Super quick turn around time, would recommend to any home buyer or seller. Thanks for everything Josh Gibson and team, I’m forever grateful - Ruta Tewelde
Property in Winnipeg, MB | Sep 2020
We dealt with Josh for a recent condo sale and new home purchase. Suffice to say, Josh is the consummate professional taking us through the sale and purchase process. He made it all feel seamless while demonstrating a level of knowledge and prowess that is hard to find in a Real Estate Agent when selling a condo. Josh was the point person for many Realtors that had a lot of questions regarding the condo and he could answer them all and many, many, more! What we appreciated most was just how open he was and we can’t say enough great things! When looking for a Realtor it’s important to have someone who’s in your corner but you should also find someone with an incredible level of knowledge, skill, and tact. Josh is all of these things and more! The final thing we’ll say is this - don’t just leave one of the most important transactions in your life to just anyone. Leave it to Josh Gibson and the team at Goodfellow Realty to get it done right the first time! - David Zyla
Property in Winnipeg, MB | Mar 2020
Josh was very helpful not only in selling my house very quickly and at the price I wanted, but he was always available to show me something new or to answer my questions promptly. Additionally, he made very helpful suggestions and gave terrific advice. - Alex Carney
Josh is very professional and easy to work with. He’s honest and upfront about the market and will assist in everything needed to get the home sold. He had my home sold in a week. - Bella